Audio-book Review
By Chet Yarbrough
(Blog:awalkingdelight)
Website: chetyarbrough.blog
There There (A Novel)
Author: Tommy Orange
Narrated by: Darrell Dennis & 3 more

Tommy Orange (American novelist, awarded MacArthur Foundation Fellowhip, received the 2019 American Book Award.)
Complacency about native people in America is a part of the message Tommy Orange sends its reader/listeners in his book, “There There”. A listener hears a message as harsh as that which exists in treatment of many minorities in America. The circumstance in which one is born and raised has a profound effect on every human being. Inequality of opportunity based on anything other than innate ability diminishes cultural identification. On the one hand, America becomes a diverse and interesting nation because of its different cultures and races. On the other, economic opportunity in a country that principally operates on a belief that wealth is power, creates obstacles for all who are not white or have inherited or established cultural differences.
Statue in Norway about the universal need for human caring and family.

“There There” is a phrase one uses to mollify a child who is being mistreated by another. Tommy Orange’s book infers most native America communities are treated as though they are filled with immature human beings in need of discipline. The truth is every human being is responsible for themselves, but when a power structure takes equality of opportunity out of a person’s control, every non-white culture becomes dependent on a dominant, largely white and male, American culture. Cultural independence often separates citizens from the seat of power, and more importantly, equal opportunity to achieve status and influence in America.

American inequality.
The consequence of inequality of opportunity is highly destructive for minority or non-white cultures that depend on American capitalism. In non-white cultures, rising unemployment, poverty, and education become centered on street life and cultural identity rather than economic opportunity. The author tells a number of stories to reveal what it is like to live in America as a native American. It is a harsh picture of life with childhood adversity, trauma, stress, discrimination, social isolation, addiction, and family dissolution. Native Americans, like early Irish immigrants, have been painted with a marked predilection for alcohol that ignores the economic circumstances in which they lived. The truth of ethnic alcoholism in America is as much a matter of loss of equality of opportunity as human weakness.
AAron John Curtis begins a wry, mordant, and witty novel that gives one an idea of how an Indian descendant might view themselves as a part of American society. However, the book loses its appeal for this reviewer by focusing on gender identity rather than economic opportunity.

Tommy Orange reports on native American dispossession, forced assimilation, family separation, addiction, and poverty as examples of hardship for native American descendants. Like most Americans, Indians live in cities, not on reservations. Their lives are challenged by the same problems of every minority in America. Orange shows how Indians are ironically treated as outsiders despite being original inhabitants of America. Many native Americans resist assimilation because of their wish to maintain cultural identity. Their historical trauma, poverty, and social stress are partly caused by a desire to have their own cultural identity. Being different is a mixed blessing in a country largely controlled by white Americans.

Indian owned businesses.
What Orange shows is, despite the trauma and hardship of native American life, survival of native American culture is assured. However, there are significant obstacles. The treatment of women in Indian culture appears as unequal and cruel as it is in most of the world’s population. Female Indian cruelty shown in “There There” seems more severe in tribal culture than in other cultures of America because of poverty and alcoholism.
Cultural diversity and survival in America are dependent on equality of opportunity.

Survival of tribal Americans is demonstrated by continuation of Powwows, literary and personal storytelling, native American business development, and a rising urban and rural identity of native cultures. Independent native businesses and native culture have become established parts of today’s America. However, Orange’s purported interviews of tribal descendants in “There There” show society’s failure to provide equal opportunity to native Americans. The consequence of that failure diminishes America and the opportunity that a true democracy offers humanity.
The success and power of America rests on its economy and human diversity. “There There” is a message that shows when diversity and equality of opportunity are discouraged, the economic health of America is diminished.






















































