AGI is Here to Stay

AGI: As Ecclesiastes notes: “For in much wisdom is much grief: and he that increaseth knowledge increaseth sorrow.” This encapsulates the risk and value of AGI.

Audio-book Review
By Chet Yarbrough

(Blog:awalkingdelight)
 Website: chetyarbrough.blog

The AGI Chronicles (The Inside Story of the Race to Create an Artificial Superintelligence)

Author: Kevin Roose

Narrated by: Kevin Roose

Kevin Roose (San Francisco-based American author, technology columnist, author, and co-host of the “Hard Fork”.

AGI is an intellectual system meant to aid human learning, and reasoning with pursuit of world knowledge, goals, and competent adaptation to the world. The concerns noted by Kevin Roose are human misuse, loss of AGI control, its influence on human life, and AGI’s independent potential for creating conditions that are harmful to humanity. The author speculates on whether humans can govern a super intelligence that is capable of manipulating human beings to destroy themselves.

FMF is a melding of corporations for development of AGI: Open AI, Anthropic, Microsoft, and Google DeepMind.

Three research companies; i.e. Open AI, Anthropic, Microsoft, and Google DeepMind created an internal safety team to monitor and constrain AI systems. This safety team worked with a tech leader by the name of Sam Altman who is the CEO of OpenAI. The group’s umbrella organization is titled Frontier Model Forum. Though Altman is influential, he is not a singular influencer of the research association. Altman represents OpenAI as only one of three founding companies’ judgement and insight to AGI that formed the Frontier Model Forum.

Sam Altman (American entrepreneur, CEO of the AI company identified as “Open AI”.

Altman loses influence in the Frontier Model Forum, according to Roose, because of his push for speed in the use of AGI. There were many conflicts among the 3 founding companies, and because of rising questions of control, governance and commercial power, the Frontier Model Forum looked for an Executive Director rather than manager of the group. The Forum picks Chris Meserole to replace Altman. As employees of the Frontier Model Forum, there became a high level of discontent with the discharge of Altman. The internal conflict calms down as Altman is reinstated to the joint venture while being led by Meserole as Executive Director.

Open AI, Anthropic, Microsoft, and Google DeepMind expand to include Amazon. The Frontier Model Forum governance becomes an industry-leader, not controlled by one person but administratively supervised by an Executive Director.

AGI is an intellectual system meant to aid human learning, and reasoning with human knowledge, pursuit of goals, and competent adaptation to the world.

Roose seems to be arguing that the complexity of AGI and its risks and rewards are too great for one person to decide on its safety and standards of use. AGI requires external oversight that is subject to government constraint and public accountability. Roose seems to argue AGI should be democratically rather than autocratically regulated. AGI use should not rest with one person but like government, AGI should be based on checks and balance of a publics’ and corporations’ interests.

Checks and balances.

Just as the President of the United States is not controlled by Congress or the Judiciary, public and corporate interests will offer some level of checks and balances. Checks and balances are a blunt instrument of control and influence as shown in today’s American Presidency. The ship of state’s government-direction is ultimately corrected through an electoral process, but the legislative and executive branches of America’s government do influence American Presidents. AGI will lead society in the wrong direction at times but will self-correct with the power of a publics’ and/or corporations’ influence. Like American Democracy, AGI regulation will be a messy process, but guarantees of human life, liberty, and freedom will offset AGI’s bad effects. That seems to be Roose’s argument in “The AGI Chronicles”.

Roose’s history of AGI implies a leveling and improvement of the general intelligence of the human race.

AGI is a tool that every person can use to gain a clearer understanding of the world. It will not make every person’s understanding equal but will open knowledge of the world’s complexity to all. As Ecclesiastes notes: “For in much wisdom is much grief: and he that increaseth knowledge increaseth sorrow.” This encapsulates the risk and value of AGI.

LIFE

Antisemitism, sexual, and racial discrimination seem like human conditions that cannot be eliminated in the world

Audio-book Review
By Chet Yarbrough

(Blog:awalkingdelight)
 Website: chetyarbrough.blog

Motherland (A Feminist History of Modern Russia, from Revolution to Autocracy)

Author: Julia Ioffe

Narrated by: Julia Ioffe

Julia Ioffe (Soviet-born American journalist, author who has written for The New Yorker, Foreign Policy, The New Republic, Politico, and the Atlantic.)

Julia Ioffe has written a fascinating history of women in the “…History of Modern Russia…” She clearly seems to have researched women’s labor, family life, reproductive rights, and war service in Russia before and after the Leninist revolution. She brings the truth of women’s equality to men while recognizing real equality is unrealized in Russia, America, and undoubtedly, the world.

A reader/listener may be surprised by Ioffe’s recognition of three women who aided Lenin in successfully creating Russia’s communist revolution. Nadezhda Krupskaya, Lenin’s wife, who is an important organizer of the communist movement. Inessa Armad, Lenin’s lover, is a feminist revolutionary. Alexandra Kollontai is a social reformer who influences Lenin’s ideas on marriage, childcare, labor, divorce, and women’s aspirational desire for independence.

Kollontai arguably shapes Lenin’s view of women in society despite inequality that prevails.

Alexandra Kollontai raised women’s issues as part of Lenin’s revolutionary agenda. One wonders how true that is in view of the evidence in Ioffe’s history of Russia. Women are shown to have been dominated by Russia’s patriarchal leadership. The treatment of women as sexual objects is evident in many examples of Russian leaders’ abuse of women. From Stalin’s domination of his daughter to leaders like Lavrentiy Beria who personified arbitrary power in the Stalinist state and the way he treated women and what were alleged enemies of Stalin’s rule. Ioffe notes Beria’s reputation for abducting and sexually assaulting women.

Lavrentiy Beria (Soviet Secret Police Chief during Stalin’s reign.)

None of the examples Ioffe details of the treatment of women is a surprise because one hears and observes it in all countries of the world. Despite the role women played as Russian soldiers in WWII, Ioffe notes how poorly Stalin treated his wives and daughter. Stalin expected women to birth and bare the future of Russia’s diminished population while working at jobs to rebuild its devastated economy. Women were expected to work in Russian factories to rebuild the economy while raising their children. Certainly, some responsibility for childcare is undoubtedly taken by men but childbearing, family care, and economic employment were all assumed responsibilities of Russian women.

Soviet women pilots in WWII.

Ioffe tells the story of Svetlana Alliuyeva’s, Stalin’s daughter, which shows how women in Russia were treated. As a child, Svetlana is privileged but imprisoned by the life she lived under the shadow of her father. Her mother committed suicide which shows how marital relationship, even in a privileged economic circumstance, is no guarantee of women’s equal treatment. Stalin’s wife chose to end her own life with a self-inflicted bullet through her heart. The character of Stalin is well documented in the history of gulags and mass murders instituted by the government during his rule.

Svetlana Alliluyeva (1970, daughter of Joseph Stalin.)

It is surprising to find a resurgence of antisemitism policies in Russia during Gorbachev’s reforms. After the revelations of Germany’s murder of 6,000,000 Jews and the world’s recognition of its horror, one can hardly believe there would be a continuation of antisemitism in the world. Boris Yeltsin officially dismantled antisemitic policies in Russia, but antisemitism remains.

The Ioffe Jewish family emigrates to America, but the qualifications of the author’s mother are not recognized in the U.S. One hears from Ioffe of their immigration status as a great hardship for the family. Ioffe shows in her 3 year return to Russia the male dominance over women which seems a backhanded way of suggesting things are better in America. To one born and raised in America, sexual inequality remains an issue in America.

Putin’s decision to invade Ukraine.

None of the post WWII Russian president’s exhibit the same level of cruelty as Stalin; i.e., at least until the reincarnation of some of Stalin’s aggression by Vladimir Putin. Putin chooses to take back the Crimean Peninsula and invades Ukraine in what is a campaign that is slaughtering its civilian and military citizens.

To many, Ioffe’s history of Russia will be surprising.

“Motherland” shows Ioffe’s deep research of Russian history and the personal experience of the writer’s life in America and today’s Russia. On the other hand, it seems some of Ioffe’s objectivity is lost. The fact that women were enlisted to fight in war and encouraged to become well educated suggests some recognition of women’s rights, if not their equality in Russia. On the other hand, Putin’s autocratic behavior has reinstated Stalin’s demand for women to repopulate the USSR after WWII by encouraging, if not demanding, Russian women to bare more children. What more evidence does one need to understand how leaders of the world ignore women’s equality; not to mention, the threat of overpopulation on earth?

“Motherland” cannot escape the author’s personal views and experience of unequal treatment. Much of what she uncovers in Russia’s history is enlightening and rings true to those who believe in the equality of all human beings. Antisemitism, sexual, and racial discrimination seem like human conditions that cannot be eliminated in the world.

BRAIN CONDITIONING

Damasio’s theory may explain why history is filled with so much human tragedy. If emotion is the source of human evolution and knowledge, one doubts humans will ever achieve broad societal peace

Audio-book Review
By Chet Yarbrough

(Blog:awalkingdelight)
 Website: chetyarbrough.blog

Natural Intelligence & the Logic of Consciousness

Author: Antonio Damasio

Narrated by: Julian Morris

Antonio Damasio (Portuguese neuroscientist, Professor of Psychology, Philosophy, and Neurology at the University of Southern California.)

This is an abstruse book to read or listen to because of the writer’s complex theory of emotions in human evolution. Professor Damasio’s research, education, and thought leads him to believe that consciousness comes from the emotions of human life. He argues that Descartes’ belief that “I think. therefore, I am” is wrong. Damasio suggests the correct phrase should be “I feel. therefore, I am”.

In contrast to Descartes, Damasio believes emotion, alone, made humans who they are.

René Descartes (A French philosopher 1596-1650.) believed thought, alone, made humans who they are.

To Damasio, feelings precede and determine human life’s reasoning abilities. He argues our biological being comes from feeling (not mind or thought) that conditions human belief and bodily existence. Damasio argues temperature change, blood glucose levels, blood pressure, and blood pH are thermostats of a human being’s bodily existence. He argues changes in emotion affect the thermostats of life that inform and educate the brain to remember and act as human beings.

 Why do humans get angry?  Why do we love?  Why do we hate?  Why are we sad or happy? (Damasio argues emotions change the thermostats of being)

“The Secrets of Consciousness” looks at the brain as a storer of information without revealing what conscousness means.

To reinforce Damasio’s argument, he writes of a patient who retains his reasoning ability and IQ but is unable to decide to act because of a lack of emotional feeling. Like Artificial Intelligence, without emotional input, a brain may understand facts but fail to use them without emotional context. Damasio argues human evolution began with emotions that trained the mind in ways that changed the thermostats of the living; i.e., whether humans, elephants, apes, dogs, or cats.

B. F. Skinner, Harvard Psychologist and founder of the Operant Conditioning movement seems to have believed something similar to Damasio’s theory.

Damasio argues that consciousness and feeling evolve based on a life’s ability to regulate their “thermostats”. A newborn possesses feelings from the moment of birth and begins learning about life from emotions that garner responses of others and affect the thermostats of an infant’s body and mind. One may ask oneself, how is that different from A.I. that creates operational decisions based on remembered facts and historical results without emotional stimulation. If one accepts the author’s theory, A.I. only presents a false flag because mere facts have no emotional content. The irony of Damasio’s theory is that A.I. decisions are as likely to be as wrong or right as one informed by human emotion. The point is that wrong or right decisions are possible whether informed by historical facts or human emotions. That is not to deny Damasio’s theory of evolution through emotion but seems to make the end result of human or animal decisions as easily good or bad for advancing life.

One comes away from Damasio’s theory about the critical importance of emotion with as much skepticism as one has of A.I. as the savior or end of humankind. Of course, that is not the importance of the author’s theory. His theory simply makes one wonder whether emotion was and is the driver of human evolution, and our reasoning, decision-making, and consciousness.

It seems his theory shows more of a threat than benefit to humanity. Damasio’s theory may explain why history is filled with so much human tragedy. If emotion is the source of human evolution and knowledge, one doubts humans will ever achieve broad societal peace.

TECH FASCISM

The rise of Artificial Intelligence is a concern of both politicians and the “Nerd…” generation. One doubts the American government will endorse or succumb to a “Nerd Reich” despite the threat of AI in the wrong hands.

Audio-book Review
By Chet Yarbrough

(Blog:awalkingdelight)
 Website: chetyarbrough.blog

The Nerd Reich (Silicon Valley Fascism and the War on Democracy)

Author: Gil Duran

Narrated by: Vincent Price & 1 more

Gil Duran (Author, American journalist based in San Francisco.)

Duran has written a provocative book suggesting there is a cabal of tech entrepreneurs like Peter Thiel, Elon Musk and others who are engineering a potential master control system that will influence and eventually dominate society. He argues this system of control and influence is creating a “…Nerd Reich” in the sense of Hitler’s Third Reich that initiated WWII.

Leaders of a “Nerd Reich”?

The weakness of Duran’s argument is that most, if not all, human beings have self-interests that are different in ways that are great and small. Theil has strong opinions about what society gets wrong and seeks tech solutions to change societal belief. In contrast, Musk focuses on specific goals, like exploration of space, rocketry, and driverless cars. On the other hand, both show a desire to control humanity’s future like the biblical belief in God’s infallibility. Thiel pursues independent human thought by entrepreneurs not constrained by formal education. Musk pursues civilization-scale engineering based on technological education of the work force. The point is that these two entrepreneurs, like every human being, looks at life differently and emphasizes their personal biases in achieving their goals. Thiel looks for ways to change society by creating entrepreneurs while Musk looks to build things that do not exist with public/private education of workers. The point is that there is no entrepreneurial Tech cabal. There are Tech individuals looking for ways to change the world but in different ways.

Brilliant minds do not pursue the same goals. Revelation comes from different pursuits by those interested in different things. Some look for universal truths of science like Einstein while others look for truth about morality like Friedrich Nietzsche. Technologists will pursue both fields of study. They may agree on one avenue of exploration and not the other. There is no single cabal of interest by technologists, there are many different interest groups. Science and philosophical revelation generally come from an individual, not a consortium of people whether technologists, or scientists, or one person. Franklin Roosevelt and Adolph Hitler were leaders with immense power, but their power came from the people they led. The same is as true today as in the times of Roosevelt and Hitler. It is up to society to decide which path, which leader, we will follow.

Peter Thiel and Elon Musk.

The “Nerd Reich” is an exaggerated view of human revelation, discovery, creation, and execution. It does not give a complete picture but only a sliver of life, a period of temporary societal success or temporary failure. There will be and surely are tech cabals today, but that is and always will be the nature of human association or what is called society. Human beings associate with each other because of common interests and pursuits. Revelation always comes from the individual with hangers on that may have played a role in new discoveries, but social change comes from the “many”; not the “one”.

Technology is a widely held interest of millions of citizens of every country in the world. However, it is only one discipline among many. Tech association within society is not a singular controller of action or outcome.

General human judgments are often based on “confirmation bias”. The nature of thought and belief of human beings is often based on evidence that others say is true without personally investigating the basis for their judgement. In addition, we tend to understand information based on things that are compatible with views we already believe. We also have selective memory and tend to forget contradictory evidence. We often fail to consider alternative explanations because of preconceived beliefs that comport with what is being stated as fact or fiction. Further, many are not willing to clearly look at the evidence that supports or denies drawn conclusions.

Reviewing the “Nerd Reich”, one must ask themselves what they have seen that suggests there is a “Nerd Reich”. Does Musk’s actions as an American government employee who fires Department heads and employees at the general direction of President Trump make him a member of the “Nerd Reich”. I think not, in view of his position of Trump’s Presidential appointment and Trump’s ordered direction. President Trump is not, by any stretch of imagination, a “Nerd…”. Trump is simply an autocrat who has risen to the level of his incompetence.

The rise of Artificial Intelligence is a concern of both politicians and the “Nerd…” generation. One doubts the American government will endorse or succumb to a “Nerd Reich” despite the threat of AI in the wrong hands. At least to those of us who believe AI is a tool of humanity, not a superior form of intelligence.

MANAGERS

Every human being has the potential of choosing their way of dealing with life. Whatever one’s role may be, the best one can hope for is to choose what makes them the best they can be.

Books of Interest
 Website: chetyarbrough.blog

“essentialism” (The Disciplined Pursuit of Less)

Author: Greg McKeown

Narration by: Greg McKeown

Greg McKeown (English author, public speaker, leadership and business strategist.)

McKeown earned an MBA from Stanford University after receiving a BA in communications and journalism at BYU. He reflects on the trials and tribulations of being a manager of events in the modern world where one is faced with psychological overload. Management is the skill of being who you are and getting things done through other people. McKeown explains how to become a more effective and productive manager. It begins with a clear understanding of what self-management is and what may get in the way of that accomplishment.

As a manager of someone else’s business, the job is simpler because the goals are determined by ownership but as a manager of one’s own time it is complicated by poor personal management skill. The idea of “essentialism” is in clearly understanding the goal to be achieved and to understand oneself well enough not to be distracted by what is to be achieved and how to organize and motivate the people who are to accomplish desired results. Once the goal is clearly understood, the end must be what ownership and oneself chooses. If the goal is to manufacture widgets, the steps of manufacturing are labor to produce a product, neither more nor less than what ownership directs. A good manager is not to focus on “more is better” but on the steps of manufacturing with an eye to trade-offs that are a consequence of labor organization and productivity.

The problem from a personal perspective is that company goals are easier to understand because they are determined by others.

Clearly understanding oneself is harder because of self-interest blind spots from being both the observer and observed; not to mention– knowing what actions are required to feel fulfilled as a human being.

The best choice in life is to be who you are, not who you wish to be.

As a manager of others to accomplish a goal, there are times when the response to a worker’s idea is no. This should never be meant to diminish the worker but to keep a worker’s eye on the goals of ownership. A good manager is respectful of a worker who offers ideas but always keeps the goal of ownership in the minds of workers to make it clear that a “no” is not to discourage a worker’s labor or idea for improvement. That which does not focus on achievement of the goal should be eliminated with a “no” but with praise and protection of those who are employed to accomplish ownership’ objectives. With clear understanding of the goal and those actions that benefit its accomplishment, a good manager offers focus to labor and reduces decision fatigue for both manager and worker.

Has capitalism lost its way in America?

There is room for criticism in McKeown’s book from the perspective of labor. As an individual working for a manager, one generally does not have the authority to decline meetings called by a manager. As a worker, one is hired to do a job or task, not to work on their own schedule, or to drop what they are doing at their own discretion. A good manager listens and learns from labor but always keeps in mind the goals of ownership. A good manager looks to labor as seeds for future managers by encouraging self-actualization and promotion but without sacrifice of ownership’s specified goals. Institutional realities cannot be ignored by laborers. McKeown implies everyone is a manager when in fact, from a business enterprise’s perspective, that is not true. Some who think they are managers, are not managers and it is important for a good manager to judge others based on achieving the goals of ownership. A good manager will rise from labor based on doing what they were hired to do, not what they think they are capable of doing. This is not to discourage labor’s advancement but to encourage it through performance in accordance with ownership goals.

Peter Drucker. (A consultant who clearly understood the role, importance, and value of competent managers.)

Peter Drucker is often quoted in this book which is a tribute to McKeown’s management judgement. McKeown also mentions Warren Buffett and the principles that made him a multimillionaire. There is a great deal of good advice in “essentialism” for those who aspire to be managers. As McKeown notes, a manager can fail when he/she becomes overloaded with workplace expectations, poor labor management, ignorance of the digital age, poor organization design, or an organizational culture that demands too much from its employees. Every human being has the potential of choosing their way of dealing with life. Whatever one’s role may be, the best one can hope for is to choose what makes them the best they can be.

DEMOCRATIC REPRESENTATION

One remains skeptical of Landemore’s solution, but America and other purported democracies need to wake up to unequal representation in government rule.

Books of Interest
 Website: chetyarbrough.blog

Politics Without Politicians (The Case for Citizen Rule)

Author: Hélène Landemore

Narration by: Hélène Landemore

Hélène Landemore, (French professor of political science at Yale University. Received a PhD from Harvard with a thesis on the idea of collective intelligence.)

Hélène Landemore has a radical idea to replace professional politicians like those leading America, Great Britain, and her home country of France by a random selection of citizens to become their government’s legislators. Landemore is obviously an accomplished and well-educated person, but her idea of reform is a problem of scale and the faults of human nature. The complexity of managing any form of nation-state’ government requires more than inexperienced leaders whether elected or arbitrarily chosen. Her weak example is the ancient government of Athens. The size of Athen’s population was miniscule in comparison to today’s democratic countries. Athens is hardly a reasonable comparison to 21st century democracies. However, Landemore notes a fundamental truth about modern democracies.

The fundamental truth of Landemore’s political idea is better representation of the population needs to be created for democracy to survive and prosper.

Governance certainly requires more than deliberation. However, the solution cannot be arbitrary selection of representatives. There have to be fundamental qualifications for those who can represent their economic constituencies. They cannot have a criminal record, and their qualifications must conform to the characteristics of the constituency which they represent.

Capability and accountability become murkier with elected representatives that are inexperienced.

As popularly elected managers of people and bureaucracies, one’s ability to be re-elected may be the best measure of qualification for office. The length of a representative’s term would be limited based on equal representation and an age limit based on an annual mental competency assessment by a board of physicians beginning at age 65. One may argue voter representation would improve over time with popular re-election by those who continue to vote for the person they have chosen to represent their needs, subject to the age 65 competency assessments. This is a controversial issue but with the availability of social security in America, this seems a responsible way of assuring competent constituent representation.

One should keep in mind that ambition is not always bad because people like Lincoln, FDR, Mandela, and Havel were driven personalities. However, poor representative elections of the mostly financially secure and privileged undermines equal representation. Professional politicians elected by wealthy supporters encourage corruption, self-serving legislation, and detachment from the general population. But critics argue that in large societies some form of political specialization is unavoidable, just as medicine requires doctors and law requires lawyers. The question may not be whether politics can exist without politicians, but how politicians can be more representative of all; i.e., including the rich, poor and those who have chosen to be or are inadequately educated.

Presidents can be corrupt, self-serving, and detached. In theory, checks and balances by a wider swarth of Congressional representatives would counter polices of a corrupt President.

Scaling of a more representative body would be the greatest challenge to democracies like America, Great Britain, and France. Potential elected representatives who know or can learn how to assemble interested participants in governance must represent their constituency. The big “ask” of these new representatives is that they also work to gain some understanding of foreign policy, government military action, budgets, international trade, and pandemic management. Legitimacy of a constituency representative would be tied to elections that are central to the demographic interests they represent. One way for America to become more representative is to increase the size of the House of Representatives. The limit of 435 members was created in 1929 when the population was 1/3rd of what it is today.

Fairer representation of all is the preeminent goal of democratic governance. Trump is the antithesis of that goal.

One remains skeptical of Landemore’s solution, but America and other purported democracies need to wake up to unequal representation in government rule. The strongest single objection to Landemore’s political idea is in a method of election and government policy creation that offers fairer representation of all nation-states’ citizens. Her fundamental truth is that today’s professional politicians fail to represent the diversity of democracies’ citizens.

LIFE PERSPECTIVE

Emerson simply asks, “How can I become fully myself?”

Books of Interest
 Website: chetyarbrough.blog

Eckhart Tolle on Great Western Classics (Reflections on the Writings of Ralph Waldo Emerson, Marcus Aurelius, Epictetus, Thomas a Kempis, and Plutarch)

Author: Eckhart Tolle

Narration by: Eckhart Tolle

Eckhart Tolle (Born in 1948, now 78 years old, German self-help author, counselor who draws from Zen Buddhism, Christian mysticism, Sufism, and Hinduism.)

Tolle offers an interesting perspective on living one’s life. The first chapter seems almost unintelligible because of its audio quality but draws one in because of the mystical sounding narration. Those who believe in God as supreme creator, or nature as the guide for life will find Tolle gives room for both beliefs. Those who are skeptical of belief in God will still be drawn into his history of the “…Great Western Classics”.

Montaigne suggests the appeal of his essays lies in the middle of the human population. Montaigne suggests the in-between are those who are not highly intelligent, who are abysmally ignorant; preferentially plebeian, and ordinary, i.e., a demeaning characterization of the middle class.

Tolle begins with a brief history of Plutarch (46-120 CE), a Greek philosopher, historian, and essayist. He notes Plutarch believes in self-observation and moral development more than social position or success as a measure of man. By writing of Plutarch, Tolle introduces the importance of character as opposed to vice. Plutarch believes consciousness of oneself is more important than worldly success or position.

Spinoza rejected the idea of a God creating the universe. He believed God is nature. In contrast, Schopenhauer’s God is “human will” rather than a divine creator. Additionally, Nietzsche explicitly rejects belief in God. Like Spinoza, the Stoics believe God is nature while Marcus Aurelius is open to a divine order but not the Christian idea of a personal creator. Plato obscurely argues a “Demiurge” or craftsman creates a world order out of chaos. Epictetus disagrees and believes nature created an ordered cosmos. Whether nature or God created the world, Tolle offers a brief history of the philosophers and thinkers of “The Great Western Classics”.

Tolle’s first brief histories are of Plutarch, Marcus Aurelius and Epictetus. Tolle suggests Plutarch is a well-educated elite in Rome who believes self-observation is key to guidance for one’s life. Likewise, Aurelius, Rome’s emperor, notes how important it is to be self-aware and to be present in the moment to understand things as they are; not as we wish them to be. It is relevant to note that Plutarch and Aurelius are wealthy Roman aristocrats while Epictetus is a former slave who is given freedom by his owner. Despite their societal differences, they appear to share the philosophy of the Stoics who do not believe in a Creator God but in living in accordance with nature, reason, and virtue.

Tolle compares Aurelius and Epictetus to Buddhists, Taoists, and (in a limited sense) Christian mystics despite their dissimilar social and political status. They both follow the path of reason and ethical practice but from different social positions. Tolle suggests both men believe human beings should follow a Stoic path by living in accordance with nature, reason, and virtue. Human beings should strive to be free of their psychological weaknesses by being conscious of their own prejudices when living and communicating with others. They endorse surrender to the present, acceptance of what appears to be true, avoidance of personal ego, and being consciously present in one’s observations and conversations.

Tolle suggests that Emerson, Aurelius, Epictetus, Kepis, and Plutarch believe that character matters more than wealth or status. Each believes self-examination is essential to one’s philosophy of life. All argue virtue is more important than pleasure. However, there are major areas of disagreement. Stoics like Aurlius and Epictetus trust reason, rational self-discipline, and alignment with nature. They believe wisdom is in understanding reality. In contrast to the Stoics, Thomas Kepis believes faith, humility, devotion to Christ, and dependence upon God are the key to a good life.

Tolle succinctly outlines different philosophies of life in his brief history of “…Great Western Classics”. Where Plutarch, Aurelius, and Epictetus ask, “How can I become a virtuous person” Kepis asks, “How can I become closer to God?”.

Ralph Waldo Emerson (1803-1882, American essayist, lecturer, philosopher, minister, abolitionist, and poet.)

Emerson simply asks, “How can I become fully myself?”

LIFE

Eric Weiner’s book is an interesting and entertaining journey through philosophy by traveling the world and offering brief vignettes of one obscure writer, and several famous philosophers.

Books of Interest
 Website: chetyarbrough.blog

The Socrates Express (In Search of Life Lessons from Dead Philosophers)

Author: Eric Weiner

Narration by: Eric Weiner

Eric Weiner (Author, American journalist, former NPR correspondent.)

“The Socrates Express” is an entertaining writer’s understanding of important historical philosophers. Though Weiner is not formally educated in the discipline, his wide knowledge from reading their written works is summarized in language that can be understood by anyone interested but not steeped in philosophy. His wide travel exposes him to many of the environments in which great philosophers created their known works. What makes “The Socrates Express” entertaining is Weiner’s clever writing and the countries he travels to, some of which he has lived in for a time. He travels to Athens, Kyoto, Frankfurt, Delhi, and the home of Henry David Thoreau who lived at Walden Pond in Concord, MA.

The “Socretes Express” explains the author’s trips to Athens, his trip to Kyoto for Sei Shōnagon’s (a lesser-known philosopher), to Frankfurt for Schopenhauer, to Delhi for Mahatma Gandi, and Massachusetts for Thoreau. There are many other philosophers Wiener touches upon but these four are good examples of the span of Wiener’s understanding of their philosophies. Not being schooled in philosophy, what Wiener explains is entertaining and interesting to its listeners and readers.

A description of Socrates is given by Weiner as one of the Greeks in Athens who earned a reputation as great warrior in war and a close friend of many important Greeks of his times. He allegedly never wore shoes and walked around Athens teaching old and young citizens about the meaning of life. Many of Socrates’ opinions resonate with the philosophy of life.

As most know, Socrates never wrote his thoughts down but became a foundational philosopher revealed by writings of Plato and later teachers like Archimedes. Weiner explains the foundational philosophical beliefs of Socrates are in Plato’s stories of Socrates life and death. Those beliefs, though not precisely listed by the author, are an unexamined life is not worth living, virtue is knowledge, the soul is the true self while its care is life’s highest priority, it is better to suffer injustice than to commit it, no one is wise including Socrates self-recognition, philosophy is preparation for death, and moral order is real and knowable through reason. Though these beliefs are only summarized in “The Socrates Express”, they are revealed by Plato’s writings about Socrates imprisonment and death.

Socrates parable of the cave is detailed by Weiner. It still means as much about humanity today as when Socrates walked the streets of Athens.

Socrates is saying human beings live in a cave seeing only the shadows of life while only a few, maybe like Einstein, see the foundations of nature that are still largely unknown.

Sei Shōnagon (966-1017 or 1025, Japanese author, poet who served the Japanese Empress Teishi around the year 1000. Shōnagon wrote a book titled “The Pillow Book”.

It is interesting that Weiner chooses to include Sei Shōnagon in his list of philosophers because she is not considered a philosopher but had written a book titled “The Pillow Book” that shows a distinctive way of thinking about life experience. Though not systematic she shows a philosophical view of life, she notes how close observations of ordinary moments in life are a source of insight to the meaning of human attention, aesthetics, and social behavior. In Weiner’s trip to Kyoto, one who has visited Japan appreciates Shōnagon’s understanding of Japan’s culture. Shōnagon explains beauty has a serious social value. She sees how seasons shape daily life in Japan and shows that women, like men, have powerful intellectual voices. She notes a good life depends on paying attention to nature and human relationships.

ARTHUR SCHOEPENHAUER (1788-1860 DIED AT 72)

Weiner travels to Frankfurt and briefly summarizes the philosophy of Arthur Schopenhauer. He notes how Schopenhauer believes most people to not really listen to their environment. He believes humans create their own suffering by always wanting something more. Like Shōnagon, Schopenhauer believes human beings need to notice and appreciate the small things in life to be happy in order to achieve some level of fulfilment in life.

Mohandas Karamchand Gandhi (1869-1948, Lawyer, Leader of India’s independence from British Rule.)

Weiner travels to India with an encomium on travel by rail. That mode of travel mirrors his journey through philosophy to give the book its title; i.e., “The Socrates Express”. With Gandhi’s brief history, we enter the philosophical belief of nonviolence as an active philosophy. Gandhi explains violence is an inadequate answer to injustice. To Gandi, knowing the truth is rarely, if ever, fully understood by human beings. Human understanding, in Gandi’s philosophy, is always limited by a human’s knowledge. The whole truth is too complicated for complete human understanding. This philosophical belief is the source of Gandi’s adherence to non-violence. Facing injustice requires moral courage; not physical force. Non-violence obviates the need for perfect knowledge while offering opportunity for human comity, self-restraint, and behavioral change.

David Henry Thoreau (1817-1862, writer, environmentalist, ecologist, philosopher.

Weiner travels to Massachusetts to visit Thoreau’s cabin site on the northern shore of Walden Pond in Concord, Ma. The original cabin no longer exists but is rediscovered in 1945. The site is marked by granite posts and memorial markers. Weiner explains Thoreau believes most people move through life half-awake and rarely notice the world deeply. He moved to Walden Pond to experience seasonal changes, the behavior of local animals, the sounds and colors of a life in the world. He defined the importance of simplicity and independence of one’s thoughts. The real currency of life is time. Thoreau is not characterized as a hermit fleeing society but as a human seeking a clearer vision of life on earth. He explores life as it is rather than as a habit of existence.

Eric Weiner’s book is an interesting and entertaining journey through philosophy by traveling the world and offering brief vignettes of one obscure writer, and several famous philosophers.

WHO ME?

As a stoic, there is a philosophical conflict between what may be a stoic’s public duty and their belief in inner retreat. The sad truth is that inner retreat is easier for most human beings.

Books of Interest
 Website: chetyarbrough.blog

The Book of Stoicism (Essential Writings on Stoic Philosophy)

Author: Manly P. Hall

Narration by: Gordon Rothman & 2 more

Manly P. Hall (1901-1990, Canadian writer, lecturer, astrologer, and mystic.)

What exactly is stoicism? The most important Stoic philosophers identified by Manly P. Hall in “The Book of Stoicism” are identified in reverse order of their deaths. Marcus Aurelieus, Epictetus, and Seneca formed the foundational tenants of Stoicism.

Marcus Aurelius (Roman Emperor, the last Emperor of the Pax Romana which is an age of relative peace, calm, and stability, Stoic Philosopher, 161-180 AD.)

Aurelius, a Roman emperor from 161 to 180 AD wrote “Meditations”. He notes that focus on the present moment, acceptance of fate, duty to the common good, and resistance to anger and corruption are hallmarks of Stoic belief. The most difficult of these characteristics is “resistance to anger”. The other noted characteristics are easier because emotions one has as they mature are difficult and varied based on familial and personal experiences.

Epictetus (Greek Stoic philosopher, born into slavery, lived in Rome until banished, and spent the remainder of his life in northwestern Greece, 50 to 135 AD.)

Epictetus lived from 55-135 preceded Aurelieus and is noted for being a Greek teacher who systematizes the ethics of stoicism. He had lived as a slave in the Roman era. He recognizes personal judgment, choice, and desire, regardless of our human circumstance, are the most important needs for personal health, wealth, and reputation. It is up to the individual to organize their thoughts and actions to become the best version of themselves.

Lucius Annaeus Seneca the Younger (Roman Stoic philosopher, statesman, dramatist, and satirist, 4 BC to AD65.)

Seneca lived from 4 BCE to 65 AD, as the earliest of the three, and is identified as a statesman who spoke and wrote about anger, the benefits of stoicism, dealing with hardship, and being happy with yourself. To accomplish that happiness, one must manage their emotions, be friendly to others, manage time for interpersonal relations while pursuing a simple contemplative life. Seneca faced death as just another fact of life with the belief that every human being has a moral responsibility for living life with the intent of benefiting society. This is an ironic belief because Seneca lived amid the corruption of Nero’s court. One wonder how he manages to live in Rome until his death at age 61.

Stoicism is supposed to be a unified philosophical system of beliefs.

Stoic belief has conflicts with rhetoric and ethics. Rhetoric is the art of persuasion through language. Ethics is the study of right and wrong. A stoic believes the universe has a rational, and deterministic order that unfolds as fate. If that is accepted as truth, it means everything unfolds in life according to fate. One asks oneself, how can humans be responsible for anything, if life is a matter of fate? The stoic’s response is that external events are fated, but human inner-responses are free. Why would one act ethically if outcomes are predetermined? Epictetus argues we only control what is up to us like Marcus Aurelius is noted to have struggled to reconcile his duty as a leader to what may be a cosmic inevitability. The tension between fate and ethical response is not entirely answered by a Stoic who says inner responses are free when the end result remains fated. The only psychological consolation seems to be feeling one did what was right despite what inevitably happens.

Then, there is the conflict between stoic emotional discipline and rhetorical passion.

A stoic is expected to be emotionally restrained but may use emotional rhetoric to give urgency to persuade another person to act differently. Appeal to one’s emotions by using emotional rhetoric is a betrayal of stoic idealism. Words matter. Finally, the stoic writes of universal social responsibility but encourages personal detachment from society. As a stoic, there is a philosophical conflict between what may be a stoic’s public duty and their belief in inner retreat. The sad truth is that inner retreat is easier for most human beings.

THREATS OF AI

Public input to AI policy needs to be solicited and incorporated in the direction of AI research.

Books of Interest
 Website: chetyarbrough.blog

Empire of AI (Dreams and Nightmares in Sam Altman’s OpenAI)

Author: Karen Hao

Narration by: Karen Hao

Karen Hao (Author, American journalist, former engineer and specialist in AI and its societal impacts.)

Karen Hao knows what she is writing about. As a senior member of MIT Technology Review and the Wall Street Journal she has the skill of a first-rate journalist to profile AI. She is an independent academic with a journalist eye view of what is happening in AI research and development.

Artificial intelligence offers reward and peril for society. On the one hand, AI can aid the world in preventing and curing disease, mitigating global warming, discovering solutions for interstellar travel, and improving the welfare of diverse cultures. However, AI opens the door to Ray Bradbury’s surveillance society, Aldous Huxley’s “Brave New World” and Philip Dick’s “…Man in the High Castle”.

AI can lead to behavior monitors that detail every person’s life and predict whether a person will benefit or harm society. Artificial Intelligence has potential for centralizing control by a minority of human beings to influence and potentially control human behavior. Human discretion and actions become probabilistically predictable by AI monitoring. Aside from the fear of centralized control by AI, Hao recounts the harm being done TODAY in developing a product that no one clearly understands.

AI labor exploitation.

Hao writes of the exploitation of Kenyan data workers who are working on Elon Musk’s OpenAI for grossly unfair low wages. AI data centers are being developed in fragile natural environments that divert the use of freshwater in poorly provisioned nations like Chile. The environmental costs of AI labs on use of energy and natural resources compete with the fundamental needs of local people. The consolidation of corporate power and use of AI is disproportionately consuming global resources like labor, land, and water at the expense of basic needs of local populations.

The theories of the utopian value of AI are, in Hao’s opinion, hiding the real harms being done to society today. AI development by a minority of businesses like Musk’s Open AI and Google’s DeepMind are changing human society today. Hao is not just predicting a future. She is reporting on present-day empire building by two companies that will impact the future of society. Hao argues massive models of AI being developed by two companies need to be modified to focus on singular societal issues rather than unfocused broad Artificial General Intelligence.

Broad international agreement needs to be created to make AI research accountable for today’s environmental impacts and tomorrows use, ownership, and influence on human behavior.

Sam Altman (American entrepreneur, investor and CEO of Open AI.)

Public input needs to be solicited and incorporated in the direction of AI research and development. The billions of dollars being spent on AI should not be limited to two or three companies without oversight. Communities and workers that are affected by AI need to have public oversight, labor, and environmental protections incorporated in the research and development of AI engaged corporations.