“The Bell Jar” is not an entertaining novel, but it offers understanding of human fragility and the possible consequences of our behavior toward others.
Sylvia Plath (1932-1963, American poet and author, committed suicide 1 month after the publication of “The Bell Jar”.)
“The Bell Jar” is a difficult book for any reader who ever considered ending their life by suicide. It is even more difficult for a male because it is from insight to a female’s interior life. It is a portrayal of depression. The weight of its meaning is immense because the author, Sylivia Plath, dies by suicide soon after its publication.
Sexual predation.
Plath describes a woman named Esther who lives in New York and has an internship that seems to have no value to her as an opportunity. She sees herself as a woman who has few chances for success in life because of her sex. She looks to writing as a possible career. She becomes close to a man who disappoints her by treating her as a sex object rather than a human being of independence and value. The loss of acceptance to a college writing class compounds her feelings of directionless and hopelessness. She recognizes there are so many possible careers before her but becomes frozen with indecision. Esther’s depression is triggered by feelings of worthlessness from first sexual experience and indecision on her life’s direction. She withdraws into the tenuous comfort of her mother’s care.
Parenting
Her mother appears to deeply care for Esther and makes arrangements for her to meet with a psychiatrist, but she fails to communicate enough for the doctor to be able to treat her successfully. The psychiatrist concludes he cannot help Esther without the help of shock therapy to reset her mind. The treatment is gruesomely explained as a painful experience that fails to change Esther’s insomnia or depression. Esther changes to a female psychiatrist but is eventually committed to a care facility that offers no relief for her condition. She has contemplated suicide by razor blade cuts to her wrists in a warm bath, drowning from a long swim in the ocean, to shooting herself.
Memories contained in a “…Bell Jar”.
One wonders about the idea of “The Bell Jar” as a title to the book. A bell jar can hold many things just like every life. However, is life as transparent as a glass jar? No. On the other hand, to others, we are observed as though we are seen through glass. We are not who others think we are but our relationship with others is based on perception whether correct or not. A “…Bell Jar” is an apt version of who we are as seen by others.
“The Bell Jar” is not an entertaining novel, but it offers understanding of human fragility and the possible consequences of our behavior toward others.
AGI: As Ecclesiastes notes: “For in much wisdom is much grief: and he that increaseth knowledge increaseth sorrow.” This encapsulates the risk and value of AGI.
The AGI Chronicles (The Inside Story of the Race to Create an Artificial Superintelligence)
Author: Kevin Roose
Narrated by: Kevin Roose
Kevin Roose (San Francisco-based American author, technology columnist, author, and co-host of the “Hard Fork”.
AGI is an intellectual system meant to aid human learning, and reasoning with pursuit of world knowledge, goals, and competent adaptation to the world. The concerns noted by Kevin Roose are human misuse, loss of AGI control, its influence on human life, and AGI’s independent potential for creating conditions that are harmful to humanity. The author speculates on whether humans can govern a super intelligence that is capable of manipulating human beings to destroy themselves.
AGI management designed to improve its safety.
Three research companies; i.e. Open AI, Anthropic, Microsoft, and Google DeepMind created an internal safety team to monitor and constrain AI systems. This safety team worked with a tech leader by the name of Sam Altman who is the CEO of OpenAI. The group’s umbrella organization is titled Frontier Model Forum. Though Altman is influential, he is not a singular influencer of the research association. Altman represents OpenAI as only one of three founding companies’ judgement and insight to AGI that formed the Frontier Model Forum.
Sam Altman (American entrepreneur, CEO of the AI company identified as “Open AI”.
Altman loses influence in the Frontier Model Forum, according to Roose, because of his push for speed in the use of AGI. There were many conflicts among the 3 founding companies, and because of rising questions of control, governance and commercial power, the Frontier Model Forum looked for an Executive Director rather than manager of the group. The Forum picks Chris Meserole to replace Altman. As employees of the Frontier Model Forum, there became a high level of discontent with the discharge of Altman. The internal conflict calms down as Altman is reinstated to the joint venture while being led by Meserole as Executive Director.
Open AI, Anthropic, Microsoft, and Google DeepMind expand to include Amazon. The Frontier Model Forum governance becomes an industry-leader, not controlled by one person but administratively supervised by an Executive Director.
AGI is an intellectual system meant to aid human learning, and reasoning with human knowledge, pursuit of goals, and competent adaptation to the world.
Roose seems to be arguing that the complexity of AGI and its risks and rewards are too great for one person to decide on its safety and standards of use. AGI requires external oversight that is subject to government constraint and public accountability. Roose seems to argue AGI should be democratically rather than autocratically regulated. AGI use should not rest with one person but like government, AGI should be based on checks and balance of a publics’ and corporations’ interests.
Checks and balances.
Just as the President of the United States is not controlled by Congress or the Judiciary, public and corporate interests will offer some level of checks and balances. Checks and balances are a blunt instrument of control and influence as shown in today’s American Presidency. The ship of state’s government-direction is ultimately corrected through an electoral process, but the legislative and executive branches of America’s government do influence American Presidents. AGI will lead society in the wrong direction at times but will self-correct with the power of a publics’ and/or corporations’ influence. Like American Democracy, AGI regulation will be a messy process, but guarantees of human life, liberty, and freedom will offset AGI’s bad effects. That seems to be Roose’s argument in “The AGI Chronicles”.
Roose’s history of AGI implies a leveling and improvement of the general intelligence of the human race.
AGI is a tool that every person can use to gain a clearer understanding of the world. It will not make every person’s understanding equal but will open knowledge of the world’s complexity to all. As Ecclesiastes notes: “For in much wisdom is much grief: and he that increaseth knowledge increaseth sorrow.” This encapsulates the risk and value of AGI.
Motherland (A Feminist History of Modern Russia, from Revolution to Autocracy)
Author: Julia Ioffe
Narrated by: Julia Ioffe
Julia Ioffe (Soviet-born American journalist, author who has written for The New Yorker, Foreign Policy, The New Republic, Politico, and the Atlantic.)
Julia Ioffe has written a fascinating history of women in the “…History of Modern Russia…” She clearly seems to have researched women’s labor, family life, reproductive rights, and war service in Russia before and after the Leninist revolution. She brings the truth of women’s equality to men while recognizing real equality is unrealized in Russia, America, and undoubtedly, the world.
A reader/listener may be surprised by Ioffe’s recognition of three women who aided Lenin in successfully creating Russia’s communist revolution. Nadezhda Krupskaya, Lenin’s wife, who is an important organizer of the communist movement. Inessa Armad, Lenin’s lover, is a feminist revolutionary. Alexandra Kollontai is a social reformer who influences Lenin’s ideas on marriage, childcare, labor, divorce, and women’s aspirational desire for independence.
Kollontai arguably shapes Lenin’s view of women in society despite inequality that prevails.
Alexandra Kollontai raised women’s issues as part of Lenin’s revolutionary agenda. One wonders how true that is in view of the evidence in Ioffe’s history of Russia. Women are shown to have been dominated by Russia’s patriarchal leadership. The treatment of women as sexual objects is evident in many examples of Russian leaders’ abuse of women. From Stalin’s domination of his daughter to leaders like Lavrentiy Beria who personified arbitrary power in the Stalinist state and the way he treated women and what were alleged enemies of Stalin’s rule. Ioffe notes Beria’s reputation for abducting and sexually assaulting women.
Lavrentiy Beria (Soviet Secret Police Chief during Stalin’s reign.)
None of the examples Ioffe details of the treatment of women is a surprise because one hears and observes it in all countries of the world. Despite the role women played as Russian soldiers in WWII, Ioffe notes how poorly Stalin treated his wives and daughter. Stalin expected women to birth and bare the future of Russia’s diminished population while working at jobs to rebuild its devastated economy. Women were expected to work in Russian factories to rebuild the economy while raising their children. Certainly, some responsibility for childcare is undoubtedly taken by men but childbearing, family care, and economic employment were all assumed responsibilities of Russian women.
Soviet women pilots in WWII.
Ioffe tells the story of Svetlana Alliuyeva’s, Stalin’s daughter, which shows how women in Russia were treated. As a child, Svetlana is privileged but imprisoned by the life she lived under the shadow of her father. Her mother committed suicide which shows how marital relationship, even in a privileged economic circumstance, is no guarantee of women’s equal treatment. Stalin’s wife chose to end her own life with a self-inflicted bullet through her heart. The character of Stalin is well documented in the history of gulags and mass murders instituted by the government during his rule.
Svetlana Alliluyeva (1970, daughter of Joseph Stalin.)
It is surprising to find a resurgence of antisemitism policies in Russia during Gorbachev’s reforms. After the revelations of Germany’s murder of 6,000,000 Jews and the world’s recognition of its horror, one can hardly believe there would be a continuation of antisemitism in the world. Boris Yeltsin officially dismantled antisemitic policies in Russia, but antisemitism remains.
The Ioffe Jewish family emigrates to America, but the qualifications of the author’s mother are not recognized in the U.S. One hears from Ioffe of their immigration status as a great hardship for the family. Ioffe shows in her 3 year return to Russia the male dominance over women which seems a backhanded way of suggesting things are better in America. To one born and raised in America, sexual inequality remains an issue in America.
Putin’s decision to invade Ukraine.
None of the post WWII Russian president’s exhibit the same level of cruelty as Stalin; i.e., at least until the reincarnation of some of Stalin’s aggression by Vladimir Putin. Putin chooses to take back the Crimean Peninsula and invades Ukraine in what is a campaign that is slaughtering its civilian and military citizens.
To many, Ioffe’s history of Russia will be surprising.
“Motherland” shows Ioffe’s deep research of Russian history and the personal experience of the writer’s life in America and today’s Russia. On the other hand, it seems some of Ioffe’s objectivity is lost. The fact that women were enlisted to fight in war and encouraged to become well educated suggests some recognition of women’s rights, if not their equality in Russia. On the other hand, Putin’s autocratic behavior has reinstated Stalin’s demand for women to repopulate the USSR after WWII by encouraging, if not demanding, Russian women to bare more children. What more evidence does one need to understand how leaders of the world ignore women’s equality; not to mention, the threat of overpopulation on earth?
“Motherland” cannot escape the author’s personal views and experience of unequal treatment. Much of what she uncovers in Russia’s history is enlightening and rings true to those who believe in the equality of all human beings. Antisemitism, sexual, and racial discrimination seem like human conditions that cannot be eliminated in the world.
Mahmoud Khalil (Algerian-Palestinian activist, former graduate student at Columbia’s School of International and Public Affairs.)
Mahmoud Khalil tells his story of being arrested by ICE for demonstrating at Colombia University in New York, only weeks before his graduation. Khalil is part of a demonstration against the Gaza war and what is identified by Amnesty International in 2024 as a Palestinian genocide. He is detained without being accused of a crime and sent to LaSalle Detention Center in Jena, Louisiana (approximately 1300 miles south). By coincidence or intent, the Trump administration cancelled approximately $400 million in federal grants and contracts to Columbia University before Khalil’s arrest.
President Andrew Jackson (1829-1837)President Woodrow Wilson (1913-1921)President Roosevelt (1933-1945)President Richard Nixon (1969-1974)President Donald Trump (2017-2021, 2025-?)
Kahlil’s book is a reminder of Presidential actions of former Presidents from both parties that have used their power to reinforce their government policies. Andrew Jackson, Woodrow Willson, Franklin Roosevelt, Richard Nixon, and now, Donald Trump, are prime examples. Nevertheless, it is appalling to see the power of a President to arrest and illegally transport and/or deport foreign immigrants who are in this country to become productive workers or to attain an advanced education.
Are Americans more or less free in the 21st century?
America is founded on the principles of “free speech”, and “due process of law”, both of which are violated in the story of Khalil’s treatment by the American government. He is never charged with a crime but is arrested, and detained over 1300 miles from his home, a pregnant wife, and their newborn baby. The treatment of illegal immigrants by ICE is disgusting but Khalil’s experience shows it makes no difference when you look like a foreigner. America’s growing reputation as a bigoted country is confirmed. Khalil’s story shows if you look Black or foreign, your chances for success in America are diminished.
“No Land to Stand On” reflects on America as a country that has a long way to go to become a land of free speech and equal rights.
The power of an incompetent President is only mitigated by legislative and judicial powers, and the limits of their term in office. One hopes the next two years are better than the last two.
“The Cost of Care’ recommends insurance companies, medical services, and government administrations focus on creating a policy of “Medicare-for-all” that treats all elder and/or ill American citizens equally.
The Cost of Care (How Four Nurses Put Patients First in a Profit-Driven System)
Author: Theresa Brown
Narrated by: Donna Jay Fulks
Theresa Brown (PhD, BSN, Rn, Author, American clinical nurse.)
“The Cost of Care” is a somewhat frustrating book to review because it notes human faults that seem to dumb-down the profession of medical care in the United States. Like all products and services in America, cost is rising. Of course, a difference is that medical service is often a necessity rather than a choice. However, like all service organizations, some are managed well; others not.
Childbirth.
The first half of Brown’s book deals with childbirth and the costs and care for young families that choose to have children. Surprisingly, she finds Midwife birthing centers provide better care for pregnant mothers than most hospitals. She highlights Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, and Portland, Oregon Midwife centers. She notes the counseling and care from “Midwife” birthing centers are less expensive, equally effective, and more comforting for both mothers and newborn than major hospitals. Brown criticizes hospital treatment of pregnancy as emotionally sterile, less patient centered, and less likely to offer the best care for mothers and the newborn. This is an observation by Brown who is educated and licensed as a registered nurse.
A major criticism is Brown’s recognition of what one might call hospital clericalization of health care.
There is a sense of medical treatment becoming a mechanical job by caregivers, including doctors and nursing professionals who show little empathy or expressed concern for their patients. Many who have been treated by doctors, nurses, or hospital admissions employees will recognize some of her criticism. Large organizations, like hospitals, are highly regulated by the States in which they exist. Standardization of service in hospitals is required to mitigate possible mistakes in medical treatment. However, Brown notes that standardization works against the care, comfort, and safe infant delivery offered by mid-wife operations.
The right to choose.
However, what the author ignores is the volitional control a patient or pregnant mother has in choosing a physician. Human beings, whether doctors, nurses, midwifes, or pregnant mothers vary in their attitudes, habits, and beliefs. Both patients and those who provide medical services are human. The best any person can do as a physician, nurse, midwife, or patient is influenced by their education and the life they have lived. A pregnant woman’s choice of service is up to her. Brown argues mid-wife’ deliveries show lower C-section rates, fewer induced births and episiotomies, and higher rates of vaginal births with infant outcomes that are equal or better than hospitals.
Brown suggests care for expectant mothers is diminished by hospitalization.
Few service organizations and their employees perfectly serve the public. If one is not satisfied with a particular physician or medical service, a patient’s options are to choose a different service, live with or self-cure their malady, or try to find another medical treatment service. If the medical facility is the only one in town and has rude or unresponsive employees, a patient’s options are to complain about the medical service to supervisors or owners of the facility. Complaints may or may not change anything but failure to register a complaint will only reinforce poor services of the company.
Aged American citizens.
Brown goes on to discuss medical services for aged American citizens. The majority of Americans cannot afford full-service retirement communities that cover all natural aging maladies of those over 65. Qualification for complete care retirement communities often exceed a net worth requirement of $1,500,000 while most aged Americans’ have net worths of less than $250,000. This economic reality makes ageing in place a necessity rather than a choice for most Americans.
Brown ends “The Cost of Care” with a practical, though ideologically idealized, idea of how to improve medical care in America. She argues for caregivers, particularly nurses, be trained to base their care on human relationship. Brown suggests focusing on a health care change in America. She argues for health care to be reorganized. Her book recommends insurance companies, medical services, and government administrations focus on creating a policy of “Medicare-for-all” that treats all elder and/or ill American citizens equally.
Damasio’s theory may explain why history is filled with so much human tragedy. If emotion is the source of human evolution and knowledge, one doubts humans will ever achieve broad societal peace
Antonio Damasio (Portuguese neuroscientist, Professor of Psychology, Philosophy, and Neurology at the University of Southern California.)
This is an abstruse book to read or listen to because of the writer’s complex theory of emotions in human evolution. Professor Damasio’s research, education, and thought leads him to believe that consciousness comes from the emotions of human life. He argues that Descartes’ belief that “I think. therefore, I am” is wrong. Damasio suggests the correct phrase should be “I feel. therefore, I am”.
In contrast to Descartes, Damasio believes emotion, alone, made humans who they are.
René Descartes (A French philosopher 1596-1650.) believed thought, alone, made humans who they are.
To Damasio, feelings precede and determine human life’s reasoning abilities. He argues our biological being comes from feeling (not mind or thought) that conditions human belief and bodily existence. Damasio argues temperature change, blood glucose levels, blood pressure, and blood pH are thermostats of a human being’s bodily existence. He argues changes in emotion affect the thermostats of life that inform and educate the brain to remember and act as human beings.
Why do humans get angry? Why do we love? Why do we hate? Why are we sad or happy? (Damasio argues emotions change the thermostats of being)
To reinforce Damasio’s argument, he writes of a patient who retains his reasoning ability and IQ but is unable to decide to act because of a lack of emotional feeling. Like Artificial Intelligence, without emotional input, a brain may understand facts but fail to use them without emotional context. Damasio argues human evolution began with emotions that trained the mind in ways that changed the thermostats of the living; i.e., whether humans, elephants, apes, dogs, or cats.
B. F. Skinner, Harvard Psychologist and founder of the Operant Conditioning movement seems to have believed something similar to Damasio’s theory.
Damasio argues that consciousness and feeling evolve based on a life’s ability to regulate their “thermostats”. A newborn possesses feelings from the moment of birth and begins learning about life from emotions that garner responses of others and affect the thermostats of an infant’s body and mind. One may ask oneself, how is that different from A.I. that creates operational decisions based on remembered facts and historical results without emotional stimulation. If one accepts the author’s theory, A.I. only presents a false flag because mere facts have no emotional content. The irony of Damasio’s theory is that A.I. decisions are as likely to be as wrong or right as one informed by human emotion. The point is that wrong or right decisions are possible whether informed by historical facts or human emotions. That is not to deny Damasio’s theory of evolution through emotion but seems to make the end result of human or animal decisions as easily good or bad for advancing life.
One comes away from Damasio’s theory about the critical importance of emotion with as much skepticism as one has of A.I. as the savior or end of humankind. Of course, that is not the importance of the author’s theory. His theory simply makes one wonder whether emotion was and is the driver of human evolution, and our reasoning, decision-making, and consciousness.
It seems his theory shows more of a threat than benefit to humanity. Damasio’s theory may explain why history is filled with so much human tragedy. If emotion is the source of human evolution and knowledge, one doubts humans will ever achieve broad societal peace.
Tracy Daugherty (American author, Professor of English and Creative Writing at Oregon State University.)
Cormac McCarthy.
One thinks of Cormac McCarthy as a recluse, but Tracy Daugherty’s biography shows him to be a young boy who is a charmer and high school cutup who outshines the intelligence of his classmates. Living and being raised in Tennessee, he lives a life of an upper middleclass son who has a troubled relationship with his father. He begins his writing life early in his high school years, graduates from the University of Tennessee, and joins the U.S. Air Force in 1953. He leaves the Air Force in 1957, returns to Tennessee, and begins writing seriously in his twenties.
Cormac McCarthy’s first published novel.
At age 31, McCarthy has his first novel (The Orchard Keeper) published in 1965. It is not a best seller, but it receives praise from accomplished writers like Ralph Ellison. It is not until he is near 51 years of age that literary success for his writing is achieved. “Blood Meridian” is published. His fame and notoriety grow. Daughterty infers McCarthy’s father read everything his son wrote and admired his son but never resolves their broken relationship. When Cormac’s father dies, he chooses not to attend his funeral.
Even though the Orchard Keeper outsold Blood Meridian, this is the novel that gave McCarthy the reputation as a great writer.
Before “Blood Meridian”, McCarthy had written “Outer Dark”, “Child of God”, and “Suttree” which were published without much acclaim. Despite Daugherty’s characterization of McCarthy as a highly intelligent writer, he did not become widely famous until “All the Pretty Horses” is published in 1992. Literary success is accompanied by substantial financial success.
Daugherty suggests McCarthy’s personal life is troubled by selfishness and his obsession to become a great writer.
McCarthy neglects his wives and family because of his driven desire to be a great writer. His first marriage to Lee Holleman lasts for two years with one son, both of which he abandons. His second wife, Anne DeLisle, lasts for over ten years but his literary ambition, as it had in his first marriage, gets in the way of the relationship. McCarthy marries two more times but his growing reputation as one of America’s greatest novelists is elusive. He achieves the sobriquet of “great writer” with “Blood Meridian” published in 1985. It is considered a masterpiece of historical fiction alongside works of writers like Herman Melville and William Faulkner.
Cormac McCarthy as a young man when “Suttree” is published.
Goals are based on plans for achievement.
McCarthy’s reputation becomes legendary after the success of the “Border Trilogy” and “All the Pretty Horses”. His critical acclaim is nationally and internationally recognized. He is perceived as a recluse, an outsider, and a literary hermit. In Daugherty’s opinion, McCarthy was a disciplined, and dedicated artist whose public image hides the truth of his peripatetic and storied life.
Daugherty argues McCarthy captures an American life characterized by violence, greed, love, and achievement of a singular focused goal. McCarthy’s goal is to be a great writer. He transforms the experiences of his own life with intensity and reality that makes his writing unforgettable. Having recently listened to “The Road”, one can see how McCarthy regrets his failure as a father. It almost seems “The Road” is a kind of apology for his neglect as a father. McCarthy’s dogged pursuit to become a great writer is based on an obsession. The written characters he develops, and life experiences noted in this biography are clearly evident in his books. Only McCarthy would know if the cost of many marriages, his estrangement from his father, and the neglect of his first son (he had a second son with a future wife) were worth the achievement of his goal. McCarthy dies in 2023.
What Daugherty’s biography shows is that success as a great writer mattered the most to Cormac McCarthy.
End Times Fascism (And the Fight for the Living World)
Author: Naoimi Klein, Astra Taylor
Narrated by: Astra Taylor, Naomi Klein
Naomi Klein (Canadian author, social activist, and filmmaker.)Astra Taylor (Canadian American, documentary film maker, writer, activist, and musician.)
Has American government become fascist? Is America being led by a Benito Mussolini and becoming more like Nazi Germany than a democratic nation?
The characteristic of a fascist nation is authoritarianism, ultranationalism, cultism, and opposition suppression designed to mobilize myth and emotion. Trump is an authoritarian. He believes America is the superior of all nations. He surrounds himself with sycophants who endorse his belief and fear his criticism. However, an estimated 59 to 61 percent of American citizens disapprove of Trump’s leadership. That opposition provides a belief that America is not and will not ever be like Mussolini’s or Hitler’s fascist regimes.
Klein and Taylor clearly mark the fascist actions and belief of America’s current president, but their arguments become tiresome and increasingly disrespectful of the power of democratic government and beliefs of an American majority. Their argument is diminished by being too judgmental, ignoring the feelings of most Americans, underestimating the power of America’s form of democracy, and oversimplifying the disgusting policies of an aged and incompetent President.
This is not a book that objectively assesses the truth of our times as seriously dangerous as they are for America and its allies. The picture drawn by these authors is a hyperbolically negative judgement of today’s American democracy. The book is returned to the library without being completed.
Thomas Wolfe shows how we become adults. He implies adulthood is a function of genetic inheritance, personal experience, and acceptance or rejection of our parents’ life experience.
Thomas Clayton Wolfe (1900-1938, American novelist and short story writer. North Carolina’s most famous writer.)
“Look Homeward Angel” is a tribute to the history of America in the early 20th century. What makes it a classic is that it reminds one of life in the 21st Century. In Wolfe’s short life, he captures a picture of America that is as reminiscent of today as yesterday. He tells the story of the Gant family as recalled by the book’s main character, Eugene Gant. Much of what is written seems like an experienced life of its author, Thomas Wolfe.
“Identity” is lost among Americans who do not have jobs or are grossly underpaid for the work they do.
Wolfe notes life is a search for identity filled with experiences of happiness, sadness, love, and loss. Our memories remind us of who we are, and how we became the person we think we are, despite the truth seen by others. Wolfe shows how humans are launched into life with experiences that make them something greater or smaller than their parents. As a child grows to adulthood, they become the sum of their personal life experience and inherited qualities of their parents.
S. J. Watson reminds reader/listeners of the nature and development of human beings.
The main character of “Look Homeward Angel” is Eugene Gant. Eugene’s story is about growing up in early 20th century America. Eugene is born into a big family, some of which die early in life. He is not the first born. The relationship between his father and mother show the trials of life between a husband, wife, and their children. William Gant, the father, drinks too much and seems to be in search of himself for a place in the world. He seems adrift with a self-destructive personality, an incoherent and somewhat peripatetic existence. He eventually settles into singular home life, but with scars from family separation and a wife who kept the home fires burning.
Can one be guilty of events for which they have no control over, or responsibility.
As in all families, every human being struggles to define themselves. Even though Eugene, his father, mother, and siblings have their own memories and history of life, Wolfe focuses on the growth and maturity of one son who grows to adulthood as a college graduate and an accomplished writer. It is the aspiration and self-discovery of Eugene and Wolfe’s engaging writing that keeps one engrossed in “Look Homeward Angel”. Wolfe is an extraordinarily gifted writer who paints imaginative, detailed, and believable pictures of an American family in the early 20th century. He portrays the vividness of life from the early 1900s through WWI and makes one think this is Thomas Wolfe’s life story.
Life’s journey.
Every child in a family has different expectations and experiences in life. Life is a singular journey for every human being. All of the Gant family members represent different aspects of life. Eugene’s mother is the anchor of the family. His father is a lesser light because of his lack of discipline, and employment instability. His sister, Helen, seems to understand Eugene as the aspirational child of the family. Eugene’s older brother and closest sibling, Ben, is a realist about the family’s instability and acts as protector of Eugene during the family’s hard times. Ben dies in the course of the story which gives reader/listeners a sense of the hardship in early 20th century America. Of course, the identified hardships of the Gant family remain in America today. That is what makes Wolfe’s story a literary classic.
Some Americans succeed in life; others fail. One sibling chooses to go to college while another chooses a different path. Each has an opportunity to succeed or fail. Education is no guarantee of a better life. However, doors are opened while others are closed without education. A minority of people become great, happy, and semi-contented while others fall into a cycle of poverty, unhappiness, and ever-present discontent. There is no clear path to success in life. One out of five of the Gant family presumably achieved fame and fortune. The other four seem to have lived a life of limited success in quiet desperation, insecurity, and struggle. “Look Homeward Angel” is as much a story of today as it is about early 20th century America.
Wolfe shows that one can never fully go home again. Eugene has grown beyond his attachment to home because the past is only a memory and his future lays before him. Time changes everything. Wolfe shows the differences in how one becomes who they are; i.e., the family we come from shapes us in great and small ways. How and by whom we are raised is always with us. It does not mean we are not different from our parents. Thomas Wolfe shows how we become adults. He implies adulthood is a function of genetic inheritance, personal experience, and acceptance or rejection of our parents’ life experience.