American

Audio-book Review
By Chet Yarbrough

(Blog:awalkingdelight)
Website: chetyarbrough.blog

The True American: Murder and Mercy in Texas

Written by: Anand Giridharadas

Narration by:  Anand Giridharadas

More mass shootings this weekend. Twenty innocents murdered in El Paso and nine in Toledo.

Who are we?  What have we become? A deplorable habit of humans is to classify others as either one of us or one of them.

“The True American” is a news reporter’s story of two Texas murders and a wounding.  The victims are people living and working in 21st century America.  By birth, the three victims are Bangladeshi, Indian, and Pakistani. “The True American” is the story of murder and mayhem that tests Texas’s death penalty.  The facts of the story expose human nature’s habit of “us and them” categorization.

The Texas’ murders could have been anywhere in America. Anand Giridharadas’ book is about “us and them” choices people make every day.

There is a causal link in America’s mass shootings that goes beyond the gun lobby and AK-47s.  Many of these horrific events are motivated by the isolation from Covid19 and “us and them “categories” that make one person different from another.

There is a causal link in America’s mass shootings that goes beyond the gun lobby and AK-47s.  The isolation caused by Covid19 raises social tension. Both guns and Covid19 link Americans to unnecessary death.

Yesterday’s examples of “us and them” in America are shootings in El Paso, Texas and Toledo, Ohio. Other examples of “us and them” mentality are our President’s categorization of illegal Mexican’ immigrants as murderers and rapists, a white man’s slaughter of nine Americans because they are Black, a Muslims’ murder of five soldiers because they are American, and the 2019 Poway synagogue shooting in Califorinia. Then there are this week’s murders of innocents at a parade in Waukasha, Wisconsin.

RAISUDDIN RAIS BHUIYAN (BANGLADESHI AMERICAN-TECHNOLOGY PROFESSIONAL IN DALLAS, TX.)

The focus of Giridharadas’ book is the maiming of Raisuddin “Rais” Bhuiyan. Bhuiyan is an aspiring American émigré from India, who is shot in the face by Mark Anthony Stroman.

Stroman murders two and maims Rais Bhuiyan, because he sees himself as a part of “us” (Americans) and his victims a part of “them” (Arab terrorists).  Ironically, none of the three victims are Middle Eastern.

MARK ANTHONY STROMAN

Like our President’s slander of Mexicans, a white man’s slaughter of Blacks, a Muslim’s murder of soldiers in 2015, and the 2019 murder in a Jewish synagogue, Stroman believes anyone that looks or acts like “them” is not worthy of “us”.

Bhuiyan’s life is worthless to Stroman because he is avenging destruction of the World Trade Center in New York.  To Stroman, Bhuiyan and two un-related Asians are terrorists because of the color of their skin.  Ironically, both Stroman and Bhuiyan, in the beginning of this true story, think in “us and them” terms.  By the end of Giridharadas’ book, Stroman and Bhuiyan realize there is only “we”.

Bhuiyan and Stroman are polar opposites in many ways but the same in some ways.  Bhuiyan is raised in a loving family in India.  Stroman is raised by an uncaring mother and stepfather.  Bhuiyan is strongly supported by his family to get a good education.  Stroman is ignored or abused by his family and drops out of middle school.  Bhuiyan excels in a private India’ school and becomes an elite citizen of Bangladesh’s government Air Force. Stroman is a “lost boy”; in and out of jail, and largely educated by government penal institutions.  Bhuiyan decides to immigrate to America.  Stroman knocks around Dallas, Texas, slipping in and out of jobs and jails.

social isolation

However, Bhuiyan and Stroman are alike in their social isolation.  Bhuiyan arrives in America without friends or family.  Stroman breaks ties with family and makes few friends.  Stroman isolates himself from society with drugs that make him belligerent.  Stroman is prone to relationships with fellow societal misfits. Bhuiyan isolates himself from society by the circumstance of being a stranger in a strange land.  Bhuiyan moves from New York to Dallas because a fellow Asian immigrant offers him a job.  Stroman is a “…True American”.   Bhuiyan is an aspiring “…True American”.

Bhuiyan’s early associations in America are with fellow Bangladeshis with the goal of finding employment.  Stroman’s associations are with outliers of American society with the same goal of finding employment.  Bhuiyan’s effort to find jobs is difficult because of his recent immigration and ethnic isolation.  Stroman’s effort to find lawful jobs is difficult because of his prison record, drug use, and volatile temper.

Stroman is convicted for one of his two Dallas’ murders and sentenced to death.  After ten years of appeal, Stroman’s execution is imminent.  Bhuiyan, in that ten years, continues his journey to become a “…True American.”  In the course of their troubled lives, Bhuiyan and Stroman grow to understand each other’s humanity.

Stroman re-imagined his life as his execution date approaches.  On the face of Stroman’s written and video confessions, Stroman either manipulates the media or has truly recognized the error of his ways. 

Stroman may have grown to understand, humanity is not a matter of “us and them” but a complicated mix of good and evil in every human being.  Ironically, Stroman’s and Bhuiyan’s journey is through religious belief, one as a Muslim; the other as a Christian.

Stroman is executed by lethal injection on July 20, 2011.

EXTREME MEDICINE

Audio-book Review

By Chet Yarbrough

(Blog:awalkingdelight)

Website: chetyarbrough.blog

Extreme Medicine: How Exploration Transformed Medicine in the Twentieth Century

By: Kevin Fong

Narrated by Jonathan Cowley

KEVIN FONG (MD, SPECIALIZES IN SPACE MEDICINE IN THE UK)

Though not precisely on point, Doctor Kevin Fong addresses the principle of “right to try” drugs for treatment of terminal patients. In 2018 the House of Representatives of the United States voted a majority for “right to try”.  The Senate rejected it.

Fong, a physician, believes exploration and extreme medicine are linked.  He believes human survival depends on that linkage. Fong’s book, Extreme Medicine, links exploration and medical advance with real-life stories of adventure, discovery; failure and success.  He argues that exploration of the unknown transforms medicine.

Jean Hilliard (Frozen for six hours in January 2018–heart stopped and was clinically dead but recovered with no brain damage.)

Fong begins with a story of frostbite in the early 20th century.  The two edges of subzero weather are revealed; one edge destroys while the other preserves life

FROSTBITE

Fong recounts the life of a mariner that dies from frostbite.  Frostbite slowly saps life from his limbs, his brain, and finally his heart.  Then Fong tells of a skier’s accident in freezing weather that leaves her clinically dead for three hours.  The skier lives; even though more than 20 minutes passed without an operating autonomic system.

It took the ski patrol 20 minutes more to dig Kristin out as she was buried head first in the snow.
“She was completely unconscious,” McAllister said. “She was completely cyanotic, which means she was blue all over. When I got down there I just opened her airway and started to clear her chest of snow. Doing so she spontaneously started breathing on her own.

The mariner slowly succumbs to extreme cold and dies.  The skier rapidly succumbs to extreme cold and lives.   To Fong, this is a trans-formative discovery in medicine.  The skier’s recovery demonstrated the value of rapidly reducing one’s body temperature to arrest deterioration from physical trauma.  Doctors who treated the skier were using extreme medicine to preserve life when history suggests she would never recover.  That extreme medicine became standard operating procedure for certain kinds of traumatic injury.

HEART TRANSPLANT SURGERY

Fong offers several more stories of extreme medical practice.  Extreme medicine may initially kill patients but become life lines to future patients once extreme practices prove successful.  Big examples are heart surgery and organ transplants.  In the beginning, physicians abhorred the idea of cracking a living person’s chest to operate on a human heart.  Fong correlates humankind’s instinct for exploration with doctor’s exploration of medicine.

There seems some truth in that suggestion but there is an ethical difference.  Doctors are taking someone else’s life in their hands.  An explorer of the North or South Pole is choosing to risk his own life in exploration.  As a patient, fear of death is a constant motivation.   As an explorer, fear of death is situational rather than ever-present.

Ethics come into issue in the doctor’s sale of extreme medicine.  Life is always, to quote a book and movie title, a matter of “me before you”.  Doctors are human.  Money, power, and prestige affect their decisions just as they affect all human decisions.  The difference is that the patient has more to lose than the doctor.

CHINESE GENE EDITING DOCTOR

A logical extension of “Extreme Medicine” is the Chinese scientist, He Jiankui, who chooses to be the first to edit the genome of a baby — allegedly to protect the baby from contracting AIDS.

the island of dr. moreau

Dr. He is criticized as irresponsible for using a gene-editing technology called CRISPR that is presently being tested around the world.  The ramification of Dr. He’s genomic editing gives rise to concern over experiments like those conducted by the fictional scientist, Dr. Moreau.

The ethics issue is exemplified by Congress’s rejection of “right to try” legislation.  A patient’s right to choose is a form of extreme medicine with ethical and, many would say, moral significance.

Living life is by nature an exploration.  Human beings that choose to explore advance knowledge.  Knowledge drawn from exploration does transform medicine.  Knowledge transforms everything in life.  Life on earth is finite; with exploration, life is potentially infinite.  However, it is self-deluding to forget the moral and ethical questions raised by “Extreme Medicine”.

KNOWLEDGE AND EXPERIENCE

Audio-book Review
By Chet Yarbrough

(Blog:awalkingdelight)
Website: chetyarbrough.blog

Brain Myths Exploded-Lessons from Neuroscience

Brain Myth's

Recorded by THE GREAT COURSES
By Indre Viskontas

Lecture

INDRE VISKONTAS

(AUTHOR) Indre Viskontas is an Adjunct Professor of Psychology at the University of San Francisco.  With a PhD in Cognitive Neuroscience, Viskontas has done research on neuro-degenerative diseases.

Indre Viskontas covers a broad area of knowledge and experience.  She offers many counter intuitive insights to human behavior and the brain in several recorded lectures.  She explains neuronal and behavioral functions of the brain.

Viskontas explains how and why the brain, though highly complex, and insightful, can be judgmentally weak, misleading, and health adverse.  A human brain can provide extraordinary insight to the nature of things and events while maintaining the body’s autonomic system.  On the other hand, that same brain can create appalling misinformation about things and events, distort the truth, and cause autonomic failures.

From regions of the brain to basic parts of neurons, Viskontas dissects what is known and unknown about brain function. She ties brain anatomy to our limited knowledge of consciousness and human behavior.

Viskontas is one of many myth breakers. She notes, the brain has adapted to its environment, but some functions are inefficient, misdirected, and self-destructive. Brain evolution is a lucky draw informed by circumstances.

The brain is not perfect. She notes that the brain is a part of an evolutionary cycle.  Every cycle of life has the chance of improving or destroying some aspect of the brain’s design.  So far, the brain has adequately adapted to its environment, but some functions are inefficient, misdirected, and self-destructive.  Brain evolution is a matter of luck and circumstance.

Giant dinosaurs adapted in their generation, but most dinosaur species died because their physical evolution could not keep pace with environmental change.  Viskontas notes the human species follows the same evolutionary path.

Luck comes from adaptation to an evolutionary change.  Circumstance comes from the environment that compels change.  Only time will tell whether environmental change becomes too great for human adaptation.

Viskontas shows the perfect brain is a myth because evolution is an arbitrary and imperfect process.  Evolution can produce human gene improvements or replicate destructive gene changes.

Intelligence

Viskontas notes current measurement of intelligence slightly correlates with brain size.  But, size matters little. 

She notes that Einstein’s brain is found to be average in size.  However, it is noted to have some differences; i.e. like the number of glia cells (chemical “information transmission” cells) which were more numerous in Einstein than the average brain.  Also, Einstein’s brain had more interconnection between brain segments than the average brain.  Bigger is not necessarily better.

The Brain Chemistry Effect

Viskontas suggests chemical imbalance as a singular explanation for psychosis is misleading.

The many connections between brain segments suggest chemical imbalance is an oversimplification of psychiatric dysfunction. Viskontas acknowledges the success of drugs to mitigate aberrant behavior but she notes that neurotransmitters affected by a chemical imbalance are only one part of a healthy functioning brain.  Chemicals in the brain are always in flux.  Drug therapy is a scatter shot solution rather than precise treatment for negative psychological symptoms.

Another often-believed myth is that people who are left-brained are logical; while people who are right-brained are creative. 

LEFT BRAIN-RIGHT BRAIN

Viskontas shows that both sides of the brain are activated when creativity or logic are drawn upon. The interconnections and malleability of brain hemispheres suggest logic and creativity come from both hemispheres and can (to a degree) come from one, if the other is damaged.

BRAIN DIFFERENCE MEN AND WOMEN

Viskontas notes that men’s and women’s brains are different. 

However, Viskontas concludes similarities far outweigh differences.  She notes double-blind experiments that show women have better memories than men when emotion is involved.  The region of the brain called the amygdala is larger for men than women.  Viskontas suggests the different sizes may account for differences in sexual behavior.

Parenthetically, she notes there is a medication bias in treatment for men and women because most experiments use men as the subject of investigation for drug trials.  Women are underrepresented in clinical trials.

EYE WITNESS IDENTIFICATION ERRORS

Viskontas and other writers have exploded myths of accurate human memory. 

Human brains are not movie projectors.  Human brains recall memories as stories; not discrete facts.  Memories are recreations of what one has experienced (both in the distant past, near past, and present).  Facts are often added, and stories are embellished when memories are recalled.  The accuracy of memories is highly influenced by an individual’s past and present experience.

Viskontas goes on to explain that life experience creates conscious and sub-conscious bias.  When past experience is added to the memory of an event, the brain recalls memory for continuity, more than truth; i.e., facts change, and incidents are misrepresented, or misunderstood.  Recalled events are biased by experience.

THE FIVE SENSES

We have five senses, but they focus on details that meld into a story that makes logical sense to the person recalling a memory. 

Viskontas notes that our senses mislead us because we do not see everything.  Like historians, we only report the facts we choose to include.  There are always more facts about historical events than can be reported by the most diligent historians.  Some facts are left out that change the accuracy of history.  That is why Ulysses Grant is an incompetent President to some and a great President to others.

HEALTHY OLD AGE

Viskontas sites experiments that show neurons continue to grow throughout one’s life if they stay engaged with society and work on learning new things. Those over 50 need to get out of their cars and walk to the store or the local coffee shop whenever possible or practical.  Stand more; sit less.

Then there is the myth of old age and neuronal decay that begins after 50.  Viskontas sites experiments that show neurons continue to grow throughout one’s life if they stay engaged with society and work on learning new things.  An important caveat is that neuronal growth is improved with exercise.  So those over 50 need to get out of their cars and walk to the store or the local coffee shop whenever possible or practical.  Stand more; sit less.

There are more brain myths exploded by Viskontas, but a final example is the myth that we use only 10% of our brain.  All parts of our brain are interconnected.  Not all parts are necessarily engaged at once, but interconnections suggests 100% of our brain is used at one time or another.

Viskontas’s knowledge and experience suggest memory holds some truth but not all the truth.

Higgs-bosun

Audio-book Review
By Chet Yarbrough

(Blog:awalkingdelight)
Website: chetyarbrough.blog

The Particle at the End of the Universe

the particle at the end of the universe

4 Star Symbol

By Sean Carroll

Narrated by Jonathan Hogan

SEAN CARROLL
SEAN CARROLL (AUTHOR)

Sean Carroll is a theoretical cosmologist and senior research associate in the Department of Physics at the California Institute of Technology.    “The Particle at the End of the Universe”, published in 2012 is focused on the story of Higgs-boson, the widely and incorrectly termed “god particle”.  Higgs-bosun is discovered at CERN with the Large Hadron Collider’ experiments done between 2011 and 2013.

The LHC enables scientists to experiment with particle physics at the most minute level in the world; at least, presently possible.  The LHC offers a mechanism for proving physics’ theories with experimentation formerly un-available to science.  The wonder of the machine is its ability to identify the remains of particles never seen before.  It offers the opportunity to see skeletal remains of the elemental particles of life.  One presumes many physics theories will be experimentally proven true or false by the LHC.  More consequentially, the identification of a Higgs-boson like particle opens a whole new area of science research and theory. 

Carroll notes that the LHC is the largest machine in the world with a 17 mile circular tunnel built underground, below several Swiss towns.  It was built by the European Organization for Nuclear Research. The LHC is a super cooled vacuum in a tunnel–designed to accelerate protons at near the speed of light for collisions that will reveal the remains of sub-atomic particles.  The acceleration is achieved by using giant magnets that accelerate protons trapped in the tunnel.  The LHC is in pursuit of the minutest elemental particles of the universe.  They are presumably undiscovered because the total energy of known particles does not match the calculated energy of a specific field.

LHC MAP SHOWING CERN SITE
LHC MAP SHOWING CERN SITE–When listeners finish “The Particle at the End of the Universe, they will understand why Higgs-boson is a magnificent discovery and the LHC is worth its nine-billion-dollar expenditure.

Carroll’s explanations of physics and the momentous importance of Higgs-boson are clear and understandable.  Early on, one finds Carroll explaining that particle physics is a misleading category of scientific research.  Carroll notes that Higgs-boson is not a particle.  It is a field.  Further, Carroll notes–all that humankind perceives in the world is made of fields, not particles.

With the advent of experimentally proven quantum mechanics, particle physics is transformed into field physics because of uncertainty. Every particle known to science is on the move.  In order for one to view a particle—a proton, neutron, electron, etc., it must be frozen in time, which is not its natural state.  Every particle exists within a field, a field in which particles are always in motion; always in one place or another.

Among many insights offered by Carroll, is the fundamental categorization of elemental particles.  All particles are broken into two categories.  One category is Fermion. The second is Boson. Fermions are elemental particles that are composed of matter. 

Bosons are elemental particles that are force fields like magnetism.
Electrons, neutrinos, and quarks are fermions, the matter of the universe.  Photons, gluons, W bosons, and Z bosons are forces acting on fermions within fields.  These elemental particles are massless.  All of these particles would remain massless without the Higgs-boson mechanism (field). The Higgs-boson field creates mass out of massless particles.

HIGGS-BOSON DISCOVERYA useful analogy reported by Carroll explains how a Higgs-boson field creates mass.  Imagine two people walking through a room filled with equally dispersed people.  The people-filled’ room is the Higgs-boson field. The two people walking through the room are added massless elemental particles.  However, one of the two people is famous.  The crowd congregates around the famous person to create a mass of people while the less famous person passes through the room (the field) unnoticed.

Carroll explains the experimental proofs of quantum mechanics are the reason Higgs-boson, or something like it, must exist.  That is why its discovery was so important.  Higgs-boson is the field in which known particles of the universe gain mass.  Higgs-bosun is the famous person that walks into the people-filled’ room.  Without Higgs-boson or something that works like Higgs-boson, life (matter and energy) would not exist.

Carroll offers other insights—about symmetry, super-symmetry, and breaking symmetry.  He touches on dark matter and string theory.  All subjects are interestingly presented.

In general, Carroll crystallizes the importance of theoretical and experimental science.

HADRON COLLIDER
LARGE HADRON COLLIDER

When listeners finish “The Particle at the End of the Universe, they will understand why Higgs-boson is a magnificent discovery and the LHC is worth its nine-billion-dollar expenditure.

INSTITUTIONAL FAILURE

Audio-book Review
By Chet Yarbrough

(Blog:awalkingdelight)
Website: chetyarbrough.blog

Fourth of July Creek: A Novel

By Smith Henderson

Narrated by MacLeod Andrews, Jenna Lamia

SMITH HENDERSON

SMITH HENDERSON (Author, Screenwriter)

On a scale of 1 to 10, with 1 the least trustworthy, a random audience survey marks trust in government as 1. Therein lies the fear of government intervention in the ideals of capitalism. It strikes at the heart of today’s public concern over economic stimulus, the environment, voting rights, equality of opportunity, police reform, and freedom.

Smith Henderson’s Fourth of July Creek is about broken lives and institutional failure.  After two chapters, a listener wonders, “Is this America”?  Henderson vivifies a part of America conditioned by high divorce rates, sexual exploitation, substance abuse, and institutional apathy.

In Henderson’s story Pete Snow is a divorced, alcoholic social worker.  Snow works in child welfare services, covering a large area of Montana. Snow makes a point of saying he is not a cop whenever he is investigating a home with children that are suspected of being neglected. 

Snow is a character that sees the worst side of human nature; i.e. like a cop, Snow is exposed to a world of human’ degradation that fills and empties his life.

Though Snow is careful to distance himself from police, he is mired in the same dark side of humanity. 

Henderson’s point is human apathy grows in some social service jobs because government lacks oversight and public accountability.  The public feels the job is getting done because there is an institution to serve the need. Henderson’s story implies the public is apathetic. The public becomes apathetic because government has a department to do the job. The public might trust but does not verify. (Even more likely, the public is consumed by their own needs and wants and ignores social services that do not directly affect them.)

DONALD TRUMP (REPUBLICAN NOMINEE FOR PRESIDENT OF THE U.S. 2016)

Fourth of July Creek infers that Presidents make no difference when it comes to broken lives of abandoned and abused children.  However, Trump has shown (often in a negative light) that Presidents do make a difference.

Over 400 immigrant children remain separated from their families because of Trump’s enforcement of a flawed immigration policy.

Henderson’s story shows that child welfare services, like many public service jobs, attract employees with good intention who succumb to apathy and routine.  The job becomes a paycheck rather than a calling.  It is not that an employee is necessarily bad or incompetent but public service goals are often not humanly achievable within strict use of institutional rules.  Institutional rules are made by people who often only preserve institutions.  The institution survives whether or not it solves human problems.

The story begins with the case of a single mother, a teenage son, and a pre-school daughter.  The mother and son are brawling with each other.  A cop is at the scene when Snow arrives.  Snow is a case worker for the family.  The mother is a drug addict.  She cannot manage her son for reasons greater than her drug habit.  The solution is to remove the son from the family to live with a relative but the relative does not want the boy. 

Children in Jail

Snow finds a foster family that takes the boy but the boy ultimately runs away after the foster family decides he is too ungovernable.

The boy is caught.  He is placed in something like a reform school.  He is institutionalized.  The boy is abandoned.

In the boy’s mind, Snow betrayed him.  Snow is remorseful but has no realistic alternative.  He cannot find the boy’s mother.  She has moved on.  Even if she had not moved on, Snow finds that the boy’s mother had sexualized her relationship with the son and could not be any part of the boy’s life.  Divorce, sexuality, substance abuse, and institutionalized apathy swallow this American boy’s life.

This sexually abused son is only a small part of Henderson’s story.  The main story revolves around family dysfunction in America.  Child abuse is bred by single parent families, sexual exploitation, substance abuse, and ineffectual public service institutions.  Several families, including Snow’s own family, are battered by divorce, sexual depredation, drug and alcohol abuse, and unavailable or ineffectual public services.

CHILD ABUSE STATISTICS

A deranged woman is married to a man who loves her deeply.  The husband is unable to comprehend or deal with her psychosis.  The husband enables his wife by isolating her and their family in the wilderness.  The children are raised like animals in the forest.  A myth about the family is created by the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives, the FBI, and DEA.  The ATF begins a covert operation to investigate the family.  In the course of the investigation, the husband is betrayed by an undercover ATF agent and becomes a conspiracy-of-government’ believer.

RUBY RIDGE (RANDY WEAVER, SURVIVOR)

RUBY RIDGE (RANDY WEAVER, SURVIVOR)

Snow comes across one of the husband’s sons and begins a case file on the family.  Snow becomes a friend of the son and eventually the husband.  This journey to friendship and understanding reveals a part of Henderson’s theme about American extremism and how it germinates and grows.

Henderson frames a story that captures American government failure.  The book can be listened to as a cautionary tale, a call to action, or just a well written tale of travail.  It is no wonder that government trust is at such a low ebb. The events of January 6, 2021 are a reflection of loss of trust in American government.

At the very least, one comes away with the feeling of how lucky they are to have NOT lived the life of one of Henderson’s characters.  MacLeod Andrews’ and Jenna Lamia’s narration add to the drama of Henderson’s expertly written fiction.

In spite of Henderson’s heart breaking story, America remains among the best places in the world to live. In retrospect, only a small number of U.S. Presidents have managed to restore trust in government. In 2021, a new President has an opportunity to restore that trust.

WORLD RULE

Tech geeks are trending toward rule of the world but humans remain too complicated and diverse for this generation of code makers and breakers to dominate the world.

Audio-book Review

By Chet Yarbrough

(Blog:awalkingdelight)

Website: chetyarbrough.blog

Automate This: How Algorithms Came to Rule Our World

By Christopher Steiner

Narrated by Walter Dixon

CHRISTOPHER STEINER (AUTHOR,NEWSPAPER-MAGAZINE WRITER)
CHRISTOPHER STEINER (AUTHOR,NEWSPAPER-MAGAZINE WRITER)

With the subtitle—”How Algorithms Came to Rule Our World”, Christopher Steiner’s Automate This is hyperbolic. Tech geeks are trending toward rule of the world but humans remain too complicated and diverse for this generation of code makers and breakers to dominate the world.

Social and political science have not reached a state of measurement and predictable outcome that reaches Karl Popper’s criteria for science. Popper’s requirement for empirical falsification is not achievable with social and political algorithms because falsification has little relevance.  Social and political analysis, even with the use of algorithms, is not science.

MIDDLE EAST MAP
Taking Steiner’s word that a Quant predicted some of the Middle East conflicts is not enough evidence to suggest algorithms rule the world.

(Steiner notes that Mubarak’s ouster and Arab Spring were predicted in advance by a Quant.) Steiner also explains how algorithms are used for personality qualification of astronauts. The idea is to profile astronauts to mitigate conflicts between humans in confined quarters during space travel. The profile is to predict potential conflicts and wash out any astronaut candidate that might mutiny during a long voyage.

PROFILING
Profiling is not new.  It is a technique used by branches of the military, and by many governments, and corporations.  Certainly, it is more comprehensively done today with computers but a high degree of error remains.

 Steiner’s anecdotes of chess players, astronaut conflicts, and poker game predictions using algorithms suggests promise, but algorithm use remains a far cry from ruling the world.

ONLINE PRIVACY
Steiner’s history of algorithm growth is a cautionary tale. At one extreme, there is a vision of a brave new world where privacy is impossible and human manipulation inevitable.  At the other extreme, is Ray Kurzweil’s singularity where genetically enhanced humans gain algorithmic capability through a meld of humans and robots.

Steiner offers examples of algorithms that have enhanced good and bad behavior in humans. Algorithms have improved customer service for aggrieved consumers by customizing responses for defective products and services. When an automated voice receives a customer’s complaint, an algorithm analyzes the nature (words and demeanor) of the customer’s aggravation and forwards a customer’s call to a person that can help resolve the complaint.

QUANTS
QUANTS–COMPUTER TECHNICIANS WHO CREATED MORTGAGE BACKED DERIVATIVES. With the advent of computer technology, the added assets in derivative instruments became so complex that individual human judgement of value is clouded.

The 2007-2008 financial crash is caused by financial derivatives designed by Quants using algorithms that multiplied the effect of human greed; i.e. millions of people were financially destroyed by unregulated financial securities, created by financial analyst’ algorithms.

AUTOMATION
Of particular interest is Steiner’s explanation of algorithm impact on jobs. Like the industrial revolution, the world’s work force will dramatically change with continued automation.

 More product production will be automated through algorithms that manipulate machines to do the work formerly done by humans. Steiner believes primary growth industries will be ruled by technology. No jobs will be unaffected by algorithms.

Steiner notes that even medical services for common colds and routine visits will be served by algorithmic analysis and drug prescription services. Code hackers will be offered great job opportunities. Call centers will become bigger employers but even those jobs will be increasingly handled by algorithms that minimize employee involvement.

AMERICAN MANUFACTURING JOBS
MANUFACTURING JOBS WILL CHANGE

A conclusion one may draw from Steiner’s book is that middle managers of call centers, sales people for algorithmic products, teachers, personal service providers, and organization executives will be in demand but many traditional labor positions will disappear.

Steiner’s book is a recruitment tool for today’s and tomorrow’s code hackers. That is where new jobs will be created. Steiner suggests that young and future populations should plan to acquire basic math skills, learn code, and plan for a future of automation and exploration.

PRACTICAL PHYSICS

Audio-book Review
By Chet Yarbrough

(Blog:awalkingdelight)
Website: chetyarbrough.blog

Physics for Future Presidents: The Science Behind the Headlines

PHYSICS FOR FUTURE PRESIDENTS

4 Star Symbol

By Richard A. Muller

Narrated by Peter Larkin

RICHARD A. MULLER (PROFESSOR OF PHYSICS @ UNIVERSITY OF CALIFNIA, BERKELEY)
RICHARD A. MULLER (PROFESSOR OF PHYSICS @ UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, BERKELEY)

“Physics for Future Presidents” suggests understanding of practical physics is critical for future Presidents.  Richard Muller’s argument is that Presidents need to know some physics to comprehend the utility of everything from energy, to manned space flight, to satellite surveillance, to terrorist use of nuclear bombs.  Muller is not arguing that future Presidents need to understand the science of physics but the practical limitations of manned space flight, carbon-based energy, satellite intelligence, and weapons of mass destruction (WMD).

Muller begins his book with the modern world’s effort to understand and contain terrorism.  Muller’s book seems apropos based on President Trump’s effort to limit science research, discount CIA and FBI intelligence, and denuclearize North Korea.

TRUMP AND KIM MEETING
President Trump’s effort to limit science research, discount CIA and FBI intelligence, and denuclearize North Korea.

Muller explores the possibility of a terrorist organization building a nuclear bomb and detonating it in the middle of an American City.  He looks at the possibility from three perspectives.  One, difficulty in acquiring fissionable material; two, difficulty of building a nuclear device and three, difficulty in delivering a weapon of mass destruction to a desired location.

Surprisingly, Miller suggests a greater danger is terrorist attack by private planes, loaded with highly flammable fuel.  Or, for a terrorist organization to use chemical and biological agents that directly or indirectly infect population centers.

CHEMICAL ATTACKS
Surprisingly, Miller suggests a greater danger is terrorist attack by private planes, loaded with highly flammable fuel.  Or, for a terrorist organization to use chemical and/or biological agents that directly or indirectly infect population centers.

9.11.01TRADE CENTER ATTACK
Muller reasons a future terrorist attack (with 1000s killed) will be like 9/11, but with a private plane filled with fuel (not a nuclear bomb) flown into a major entertainment event.

Miller believes practical physics will determine the next world terrorist attack.  Miller argues that the simplest plan will have the greatest impact.  (Of course, there is also the implied psychology of terrorism.)  Muller reasons a future terrorist attack (with 1000s killed) will be like 9/11, but with a private plane filled with fuel (not a nuclear bomb) flown into a major entertainment event.

There are a number of counter-intuitive insights in “Physics for Future Presidents”.  Muller believes manned space flight is a waste of money.  He argues that most of the greatest innovations in science have come from unmanned space flight.  Weather satellites, spy satellites, entertainment satellites, global positioning satellites, drones, exploration of planets and the solar system have all come from unmanned space flight.  Muller believes there is a time for manned space flight but not now.  It is too dangerous and produces little new-science.  He implies America should primarily invest in unmanned space flight.

CURIOSITY--FIRST -SELFIE- IN 2015 ON MARS
CURIOSITY–FIRST -SELFIE- IN 2015 ON MARS (Muller believes there is a time for manned space flight but not now.  It is too dangerous and produces little new-science.  He implies America should primarily invest in unmanned space flight.)

DR. STRANGLOVE
Dr. Strangelove- Richard Muller, at times, seems to stand at the side of fictional character Dr. Strangelove.(Movie titled “How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the Bomb)

Richard Muller, at times, seems to stand at the side of fictional character Dr. Strangelove.  He describes historical information about radiation poisoning from nuclear bombs and accidents.  Muller notes that statistical deaths from war (the Nagasaki and Hiroshima bombing), Three Mile Island, and Chernobyl show that deaths from nuclear radiation is small in comparison to terrorist events initiated by simple, practical, and conventional physics.

Muller argues that nuclear power can be used as a fail-safe source of energy by using the latest technology for nuclear power plants.  The latest technology (actually first used in the 1960s by Germany) is a pebble bed reactor (PBR).  It is considered safe because it does not rely on water cooling of the nuclear core in the event of an accident.

PEBBLE BED REACTOR IN WEST GERMANY
PEBBLE BED REACTOR IN WEST GERMANY – Muller argues that nuclear power can be used as a fail-safe source of energy by using the latest technology for nuclear power plants.  The latest technology (actually first used in the 1960s by Germany) is a pebble bed reactor (PBR).  It is considered safe because it does not rely on water cooling of the nuclear core in the event of an accident.

YUCCA MOUNTAIN NUCLEAR WASTE DEPOSITORY NEAR LAS VEGAS, NEVADA
YUCCA MOUNTAIN NUCLEAR WASTE DEPOSITORY NEAR LAS VEGAS, NEVADA (Richard Muller believes Yucca Mountain is an adequately safe repository for nuclear waste that should be reopened.)

This is unlikely to be a popular book in Las Vegas, Nevada. Among other controversial subjects, Richard Muller believes Yucca Mountain is an adequately safe repository for nuclear waste that should be reopened.  His argument largely rests on the science of probability.  Muller infers that natural radiation in Colorado is as toxic as the probability of radiation leaks from stored nuclear waste at Yucca Mountain.

Muller argues that revision of nuclear construction standards in the United States would make construction of pebble bed reactors less expensive than conventional American nuclear facilities.  The added benefit is a safer energy source that reduces the need for carbon based energy supplies that increase global warming.  A large part of Muller’s argument for the use of more nuclear power is based on the generally accepted scientific belief that global warming exists and is most likely caused by human activity.

GLOBAL WARMING
A large part of Muller’s argument for the use of more nuclear power is based on the generally accepted scientific belief that global warming exists and is most likely caused by human activity.

Muller spends a great deal of time explaining that global warming is not a 100% certainty but, in probability terms, is highly likely and largely related to carbon-based energy use.  He notes that use of carbon-based energy is likely to increase with China and India’s continued economic growth.  Muller creates a sense of urgency in creating other sources of energy.  He strongly urges increasing motor vehicle mileage requirements but questions the viability of battery operated vehicles.  Muller believes the costs of battery replacement will drive consumers back to carbon-based energy models.

ELON MUSK ROLLS THE DICE AGAIN BY PURCHASING SOLAR CITY, THE LARGEST SOLAR CONVERSION COMPANY IN THE U.S.
ELON MUSK ROLLS THE DICE AGAIN BY PURCHASING SOLAR CITY, THE LARGEST SOLAR CONVERSION COMPANY IN THE U.S.–Muller sees potential in solar and wind energy production but believes conservation will do more short-term good than any new source of energy.

Muller sees potential in solar and wind energy production but believes conservation will do more short-term good than any new source of energy.  He clearly sees that the cost of energy is the primary driver of technological innovation.  As long as oil and coal are less expensive than other sources of energy, they will remain the primary source of power.  With that realization, Muller insists on technological innovation in conservation because it motivates the consumer to become a part of the energy-crises’.  Consumer’ participation is guaranteed by savings received from use of more energy-efficient devices.

The key to the world’s future is energy.  Muller believes the short-term solution is conservation.  He believes long-term solution revolves around nuclear fission and fusion.  Fusion is a longer term prospect but offers an infinite source of energy.  Fission is shown to work now, with probabilities of failure that can be improved upon.

This circles back to the critical importance of storing nuclear waste.  Muller notes that the fragmented system of nuclear storage in the United States is a bigger risk to the environment than having it located in a limited number of specifically designed storage locations.  Yucca Mountain fits Muller’s criteria for safe storage of nuclear waste.  He acknowledges that nuclear accidents may occur but the probability of an accident at Yucca Mountain is less than the probability of accident at other relatively unsecured and fragmented sites.

PROBABILITYThe physics that Muller insists Presidents must understand is that scientific proof is a matter of probability; not absolute certainty.  Muller warns Presidents to not be misled by cherry-picking fact finders that have objectives that are not related to practical physics.  Even if there is no certainty in science, knowing probabilities offer a basis for informed decision.

 

TODAY’S LUDDITES

Audio-book Review
By Chet Yarbrough

(Blog:awalkingdelight)
Website: chetyarbrough.blog

The Glass Cage-Automation and Us

By: Nicholas Carr

Narrated by: Jeff Cummings

NICHOLAS G. CARR (AMERICAN WRITER-FORMER EDITOR OF HARVARD BUISNESS REVIEW)

NICHOLAS G. CARR (AMERICAN WRITER-FORMER EDITOR OF HARVARD BUSINESS REVIEW)

The Glass Cage, written by Harvard alumnus Nicholas Carr, ironically places him in the shoes of an uneducated English textile artisan of the 19th century, known as a Luddite.

Luddites protested against the industrial revolution because machines were replacing jobs formerly done by laborers.  Just as the Luddites fomented arguments against mechanization, Carr argues automation creates unemployment and diminishes craftsmanship.

WORKMEN TAKE OUT THEIR ANGER ON MACHINES DURING THE INDUSTRIAL REVOLUTION. (Just as the Luddites fomented arguments against mechanization, Carr argues automation creates unemployment and diminishes craftsmanship.)

Workmen take out their anger on the machines

Carr carries the Luddite argument a step further by inferring a mind’s full potential may only be achieved through a conjunction of mental and physical labor.  Carr posits the loss of physical ability to make and do things diminishes civilization by making humans too dependent on automation.

There is no question that employment was lost in the industrial revolution; just as it is in the automation age, but jobs have been and will continue to be created as the world adjusts to this new stage of productivity.

INDUSTRIAL REVOLUTION

Unquestionably, the advent of automation is traumatic but elimination of repetitive industrial labor by automation is as much a benefit to civilization as the industrial revolution was to low wage workers spinning textile.

The Covid19 pandemic of 2020 will accelerate world’ transition to automation. Though this book is written earlier than the pandemic’s economic consequence, corporations are reevaluating the necessity for office buildings to conduct their business. More and more employees will work from home.

Employment adjustment is traumatic.  The trauma of this age is that work with one’s hands is being replaced by work with one’s brain.  The education of the world needs to catch up with socio-economic change; just as labor did in the 20th century.  To suggest humans do not learn when they cannot fly a plane, build a house, or construct an automobile with their own hands is a specious argument. 

Houses and cars have not been built by one person since humans lived in caves and iron horses replaced carriage horses.  Houses and cars were built by teams of people who worked with their hands but only on specific tasks.  Those teams of people were managed by knowledge workers.

ASSEMBLY LINE WORK

Service and education for society are the keys to the transition from industrialization to automation.

QUANTS

Automation of tasks reduces the mind numbing, low pay work of laborers.  Automation turns manual labor into the development and education of people who design hardware and software to execute tasks that result in more safely flown planes, new houses, new cars, new refrigerators, so on and so on.

Carr suggests that airplane pilots should be given more control over automated planes they fly despite the facts he quotes that clearly show plane crashes kill fewer people today than ever in history.  They are bigger, faster, and more complicated to fly.  The argument that pilots need to learn how to fly a jumbo jet when automation fails is like telling a farmer to pull out his scythe to harvest the wheat because the thresher quit working.

Carr’s argument is that pilots have forgotten how to fly because automation replaced their skill set.  To state the obvious, planes are not what they were 100 or even 10 years ago.

WRIGHT UNPOWERED AIRCRAFT

One might argue that Boeing’s 737 Max mistakes are evidence that Carr is correct in suggesting planes have become too complicated, but it ignores the reality of mistakes have always being made by humans. Humans are preternaturally motivated by self-interest.

Boeing’s leaders made mistakes in not fully analyzing and disclosing risks of 737 changes, and in not adequately training airline pilots on the safety features of the plane.

Carr raises a morality argument for not saving life when an automated machine makes a decision rather than a human being.  One can suggest an example of how an automated machine is more likely to make the right decision than a human.

For example, presume a driver-less car is programmed to save its occupant when an injured bicyclist is laying in the street around a blind curve. A fast moving automated car with a family inside, with mountain cliffs on both sides of the road, will drive over the bicyclist without conscience.  The bicyclist is dead but the car passengers are alive.   If the car is driven by a person, both the cyclist and the family are likely dead. 

THINKING SLOW
Carr’s argument is that humans need to make their own intuitive decisions.  As pointed out by Daniel Kahneman in “Thinking Fast and Slow”, the primary “think fast” mode in humans is intuition, which is often wrong.

Without doubt, many automation errors (e.g., the 737 Max) have been and will be made in the future, but to suggest automation is not good for society is as false as the Luddites arguments about industrialization.

This period of the world’s adjustment is horrendously disruptive.  It is personal to every parent or person that cannot feed, clothe, and house their family or themselves because they have no job.

Decrying the advance of automation is not the answer.  Making the right political decisions about how to help people make job transitions is what will advance civilization.

MAR’S ROVER

Audio-book Review
By Chet Yarbrough

(Blog:awalkingdelight)
Website: chetyarbrough.blog

Mars Rover Curiosity: An Inside Account from Curiosity’s Chief Engineer

Written by: Rob Manning, William L. Simon

Narrated by:  Bronson Pinchot

This antenna-tailed super dog, and a Rover named Opportunity, are in the news this month.  After analysis of elemental particles by Curiosity, organic molecules are discovered.  An astro-biologist at Utrecht University in the Netherlands suggests life may have existed or originated on Mars.

Curiosity is a mechanical, one-eyed, six wheeled, antenna-tailed super dog.  It can stiff the air, drill rocks, analyze elemental particles, roam a countryside at a snail’s pace (300 feet per hour), and talk to humans.  Its language is in 1s and 0s.  It speaks to Earth from Mars across 49 million miles of space with a message that continues to amaze and encourage human exploration of the universe.

Curiosity Rover Animation:

Sadly, it was reported on February 13, 2019–that an earlier Mars Rover died. It was called Opportunity. Curiosity, according to a “Life Science” article, cannot repair Opportunity because of time and distance.

A slightly earlier Mars Rover called Sprit, a twin of Opportunity, died on March 20, 2010.

However, like the movie musical “Don’t Cry for Me Argentina”, we should not mourn their loss. Both of these earlier rovers outlast their expected lives. In addition to “Curiosity”, more is yet to come. On this Thursday, 2.19.2021 @ 3:55 pm EST, a new rover named “Perseverance” is scheduled to land in the Jerzero Crater of Mars.

PLANETS AROUND OUR SUN

Robert Manning, in collaboration with William Simon (a ghost writer), reflects on the technological feat of creating and delivering a robotic laboratory to the fourth rock from the sun.

Curiosity launched on November 26, 2011 to arrive on Mars August 6, 2012.  It landed on the Aeolis Palus plain, a crater that may be an ancient lake bed.  Robert Manning, in collaboration with William Simon (a ghost writer), reflects on the technological feat of creating and delivering a robotic laboratory to the fourth rock from the sun.  Manning heads a team of NASA scientists and engineers to design the latest land rover, called Curiosity, to explore Mars.

The first 12 months of Curiosity’s First Year on Mars:

In June 2018, Curiosity continues to explore Mars and deliver information on the history of earth’s mysterious neighbor.

What Curiosity is Discovering:

Curiosity is meant to search for artifacts of life on Mars while testing the potential for colonization of another planet.  To date, no definitive answers are given but Manning’s story suggests most of the building blocks of life were at one time present on Mars.  Now, it appears Manning’s story is tentatively confirmed.

Life on Mars?:

The primary atmospheric conditions of Mars are made of carbon dioxide and some water vapor as opposed to nitrogen, oxygen, argon, and other elements of earth.  The average temperature on Mars is 81 degrees Fahrenheit versus 57 degrees on Earth (a misleading metric because of the huge extremes on Mars).  Mars gravity is only .375 that of Earth which has significant ramification for sustainability of human life on the planet.

No indisputable historical evidence of life on Mars has been discovered but the existence of fluctuating amounts of methane in the atmosphere may mean Mars is geologically active and holds the potential for microscopic life.  Methane contains hydrogen and carbon but, with little discovered oxygen, there is limited chance of any life form representative of earth; at least, that is larger than a microbe.

mar's landing sites

“Mars Rover Curiosity” and “Perseverance” are a tribute to NASA and its organizational skill in achieving a land mark experiment in human exploration.  In listening to Manning’s story, one feels they are on the edge of a continent in the 15th century, planning to sail to an unexplored place to find answers about what there is beyond imagination.

“Mars Rover Curiosity” is a tribute to NASA and its organizational skill in achieving a land mark experiment in human exploration.  In listening to Manning’s story, one feels they are on the edge of a continent in the 15th century, planning to sail to an unexplored place to find answers about what there is beyond imagination.  NASA’s contribution to science and a possible future for humanity seems inferred by Manning’s story; particularly in light of current scientific evidence for Earth’s global warming.

Curiosity’s exploration (though only a mechanical creation of NASA) reminds one of Marco Polo, Vasco da Gama, Christopher Columbus, Magellan, Cortes, and Neil Armstrong in their discovery of new continents.

WAR’S HARD PART

Audio-book Review
By Chet Yarbrough

(Blog:awalkingdelight)
Website: chetyarbrough.blog

Fives and Twenty-Fives Fives and Twenty-Fives

Written by: Michael Pitre

Narration by:  Kevin T. Collins, Nick Sullivan, Jay Snyder, Fajer Al-Kaisi

MICHAEL PITRE (AUTHOR, FORMER MARINE)
MICHAEL PITRE (AUTHOR, FORMER MARINE)

The simple part of any war is having friends and enemies; the hard part is in knowing the difference.  “Fives and Twenty Fives” shows the simplicity and complexity of all wars.  Any veteran of the American military knows that part of basic training is building a team of soldiers to form a comradeship as strong as civilian friendship.  However, the difference between civilian and military friendship is the underlying command and control requirements of military organizations.

The author of “Fives and Twenty Fives” is an ex-Marine.  His novel is about friendship; i.e. more fundamentally about friendship on both sides of a war.

IRAQ INVASION
The author of “Fives and Twenty Fives” is an ex-Marine.  His novel is about friendship; i.e. more fundamentally about friendship on both sides of a war.

IRAQ INTERPRETERS
Unlike the American Civil War, the war in Iraq requires language interpreters.  Most interpreters are in-country natives and have not gone through conventional military basic training.

The theater of war in Michael Pitre’s novel is Iraq.  Unlike the American Civil War, the war in Iraq requires language interpreters.  Most interpreters are in-country natives and have not gone through conventional military basic training.  Command and control is learned by most of these interpreters “on the fly”.  Friendship is earned by experience rather than training.  Pitre introduces Dodge, the Iraqi interpreter, for a Marine team led by Lieutenant Donovan.

Dodge introduces an underlying theme of “Fives and Twenty Fives” in a conversation with Lieutenant Donovan.  Dodge explains that he has no friends because when one chooses friends, the choice entails responsibility and accountability.  Dodge is a Sunni, the religious faction associated with Saddam Hussein.  He speaks fluent English and studies Huckleberry Finn, a book he carries with him everywhere, to better understand American culture.  There are several allusions to the story of Huckleberry Finn that reinforce the theme of friendship; i.e. its implied responsibility and accountability.

US INTERPRETER IN IRAQ DENIED AMERICAN GREEN CARD
During his nearly four years as a translator for U.S. forces in Iraq, Saman Kareem Ahmad was known for bravery and hard work.  However, like one of Pitre’s  main characters, “Dodge”, Ahmad is denied an American green card at the end of the war.

COMPASSION ON THE BATTLEFIED IN IRAQ
COMPASSION ON THE BATTLEFIELD IN IRAQ – It is not exactly clear but Dodge seems to have chosen, by circumstance of war, to support freedom by making friends with a platoon medic that is singularly focused on saving lives.

Dodge’s father led the Agricultural Ministry of Saddam Hussein.  His father became a leader of the resistance to America’s invasion of Iraq.  Dodge loves his father but chooses to stay at an Iraqi university rather than follow him into the resistance.  It is not exactly clear but Dodge seems to have chosen, by circumstance of war, to support freedom by making friends with a platoon medic that is singularly focused on saving lives.

drug use in war
When a platoon soldier is ambushed, Dodge’s medic-friend is restrained by Lieutenant Donovan because he believes the soldier is dead.  After the incident, the medic turns to drug addiction to escape the reality of his friend’s death.

When a platoon soldier is ambushed, Dodge’s medic-friend is restrained by Lieutenant Donovan because he believes the soldier is dead.  After the incident, the medic turns to drug addiction to escape the reality of his friend’s death.  The medic is brought up on charges when the Lieutenant reports him for suspected drug use.  He receives a general discharge which affects his future civilian life.  The Lieutenant chooses not to be the medic’s friend in that arrest incident but meets the medic after the war with a different perspective; maybe not as friends, but as fellow human beings intimately affected by war.

ZINE EL ABIDINE BEN ALI (2ND PRESIDENT OF TUNESIA SENTENCED FOR MONEY LAUNDERING AND DRUG TRAFFICING)
ZINE EL ABIDINE BEN ALI (2ND PRESIDENT OF TUNISIA SENTENCED FOR MONEY LAUNDERING AND DRUG TRAFFICKING) Later in Pitre’s story, a reader listener finds Dodge chooses to become a part of a resistance to the repressive regime of Ben Ali in Tunisia.

Later in the story, a reader listener finds Dodge chooses to become a part of a resistance to the repressive regime of Ben Ali in Tunisia.  Dodge becomes friends with the resistance movement that needs his English-speaking voice to tell the world of Ben Ali’s repression.  Dodge is not a Tunisian but recognizes the human drive to resist oppression, and the need to be part of something greater than oneself.  Dodge chooses to be a friend of the oppressed.

Michael Pitre compels a listener to look at mistakes made by America in Iraq.  It may have been morally right to remove Saddam Hussein.  However, the decision to deny participation by Hussein’s army officers and Hussein’ administrative personnel in government transition was an error of epic consequence.

Vetted Hussein army officers and administrative personnel, with monitored performance measures, might have avoided Iraq’s spiral into chaos.  One considers the value of interpreters like Dodge who are from families that worked in the corrupt Hussein administration.  Dodge appears to have an inner moral compass that could have helped America in its intent to provide a pacific transition from totalitarianism to peace in Iraq.

There are good and bad people in every government.  Undoubtedly, there were some Iraqi Army leaders and Hussein administrators that could have become friends rather than enemies of fellow Iraqis and American’ invaders.   If America’s leaders had been more discriminating and understanding, ISIL may have never risen.  The simple part of any war is having friends and enemies; the hard part is in knowing the difference.

Post script: Now America is leaving Afghanistan.  One hopes those Afghani’s that served NATO and America’s involvement in Afghanistan will not be treated as forgotten friends.  Since Vietnam,  one doubts history will either justify or vindicate American military intervention in other countries.